Keck School of Medicine, University of Southern California, Department of Emergency Medicine, Los Angeles, California.
University of Washington, Department of Biomedical Informatics and Medical Education, Seattle, Washington.
West J Emerg Med. 2020 Dec 10;22(1):26-32. doi: 10.5811/westjem.2020.10.49135.
Educational podcasts are used by emergency medicine (EM) trainees to supplement clinical learning and to foster a sense of connection to broader physician communities. Yet residents report difficulties remembering what they learned from listening, and the features of podcasts that residents find most effective for learning remain poorly understood. Therefore, we sought to explore residents' perceptions of the design features of educational podcasts that they felt most effectively promoted learning.
We used a qualitative approach to explore EM trainees' experiences with educational podcasts, focusing on design features that they found beneficial to their learning. We conducted 16 semi-structured interviews with residents from three institutions from March 2016-August 2017. Interview transcripts were analyzed line-by-line using constant comparison and organized into focused codes, conceptual categories, and then key themes.
The five canons of classical rhetoric provided a framework for thematically grouping the disparate features of podcasts that residents reported enhanced their learning. Specifically, they reported valuing the following: 1) Invention: clinically relevant material presented from multiple perspectives with explicit learning points; 2) Arrangement: efficient communication; 3) Style: narrative incorporating humor and storytelling; 4) Memory: repetition of key content; and 5) Delivery: short episodes with good production quality.
This exploratory study describes features that residents perceived as effective for learning from educational podcasts and provides foundational guidance for ongoing research into the most effective ways to structure medical education podcasts.
教育播客被急诊医学(EM)受训者用于补充临床学习,并培养与更广泛的医师社区的联系感。然而,住院医师报告说,他们在记忆从收听中学到的内容方面存在困难,并且对于住院医师来说,对学习最有效的播客功能仍了解甚少。因此,我们试图探讨住院医师对他们认为最能有效促进学习的教育播客设计功能的看法。
我们采用定性方法探讨急诊医学受训者的教育播客体验,重点关注他们认为对学习有益的设计功能。我们于 2016 年 3 月至 2017 年 8 月在三个机构进行了 16 次半结构化访谈。访谈记录逐行使用恒比比较进行分析,并组织成重点代码、概念类别,然后是主要主题。
古典修辞学的五个法则为主题分组提供了一个框架,将住院医师报告的增强其学习效果的不同播客功能组合在一起。具体来说,他们重视以下几点:1)发明:从多个角度呈现与明确学习要点相关的临床相关材料;2)安排:高效沟通;3)风格:包含幽默和讲故事的叙述;4)记忆:重复关键内容;5)交付:具有良好制作质量的短集。
这项探索性研究描述了住院医师认为从教育播客中学习有效的功能,并为正在进行的研究提供了基础指导,以了解构建医学教育播客的最有效方法。