Department of Radiology, Kangbuk Samsung Hospital, Sungkyunkwan University School of Medicine, Seoul, Republic of Korea.
Department of Radiology, Kangbuk Samsung Hospital, Sungkyunkwan University School of Medicine, Seoul, Republic of Korea.
Eur J Radiol. 2021 Feb;135:109405. doi: 10.1016/j.ejrad.2020.109405. Epub 2020 Nov 11.
To analyze the quantitative and qualitative image quality of computed tomography (CT) of the extremities (shoulder, wrist, pelvis, and ankle joints) with low-dose radiation and standard-dose radiation.
In this study, we included 400 individuals who underwent CT of the extremities, comprising 50 cases of each joint (shoulder, wrist, pelvis, and ankle) at low and standard dose regimens. Low-dose CTs were performed using identical voltage and parameters with the exception of decreased (half of standard dose) tube current. Low-dose and standard-dose images were compared in terms of radiation dose, objective image quality according to the standard deviation (SD) of the Hounsfield unit value of the medulla, cortex, muscle, subcutaneous fat, and air, and subjective image quality according to noise, sharpness, diagnostic acceptability, and artifacts.
In the shoulder and pelvis, the mean value of the SD for all tissue on low dose CT images was significantly higher than that of standard dose CT, except for the SD of cortex in the shoulder joint and marrow in the pelvis. In the wrist, the mean value of the SD for all tissue was not significantly different between low dose and standard CT (p > 0.05). In the ankle, the mean value of the SD of the medulla and cortex was not different (p > 0.05), but the remaining measurements were significantly higher in low dose CT. Subjective image quality in the shoulder and pelvis were significantly reduced in low dose CT. In the wrist, all categories of subjective image quality except artifacts were similar. In the ankle, all categories of subjective image quality except for artifacts were degraded in low dose CT.
Objective image noise is more increased in low dose CT images of the shoulder and pelvis. Although diagnostic performance was acceptable, mean subjective image quality also decreased. In the wrist, objective image noise and subjective image quality were not degraded in low dose CT. In the ankle, some measurements of objective and subjective image quality were similar between low dose and standard dose CT.
分析四肢(肩部、腕部、骨盆和踝关节)低剂量和标准剂量辐射 CT 的定量和定性图像质量。
本研究纳入了 400 名接受四肢 CT 检查的个体,每个关节(肩部、腕部、骨盆和踝关节)各有 50 例,分别采用低剂量和标准剂量方案进行 CT 检查。低剂量 CT 采用相同的电压和参数进行检查,仅管电流降低(标准剂量的一半)。比较了低剂量和标准剂量图像的辐射剂量、根据骨髓、皮质、肌肉、皮下脂肪和空气的亨氏单位值标准差(SD)评估的客观图像质量,以及根据噪声、锐度、诊断可接受性和伪影评估的主观图像质量。
在肩部和骨盆中,除了肩部关节皮质和骨盆骨髓的 SD 外,低剂量 CT 图像中所有组织的 SD 均值均显著高于标准剂量 CT。在腕部,低剂量和标准 CT 之间所有组织的 SD 均值无显著差异(p>0.05)。在踝关节,骨髓和皮质的 SD 均值无差异(p>0.05),但其余测量值在低剂量 CT 中显著升高。低剂量 CT 中肩部和骨盆的主观图像质量显著降低。在腕部,除了伪影之外,所有主观图像质量类别均相似。在踝关节,除了伪影之外,所有主观图像质量类别均在低剂量 CT 中降低。
肩部和骨盆的低剂量 CT 图像中客观图像噪声增加更明显。虽然诊断性能可接受,但平均主观图像质量也降低。在腕部,低剂量 CT 中客观图像噪声和主观图像质量未降低。在踝关节,低剂量和标准剂量 CT 之间一些客观和主观图像质量测量值相似。