Dantas Fernando Luiz R, Dantas François, Caires Antônio Carlos, Botelho Ricardo V
Neurological Surgery, Biocor Instituto, Belo Horizonte, BRA.
Neurological Surgery, Hospital Vila da Serra, Belo Horizonte, BRA.
Cureus. 2020 Dec 13;12(12):e12050. doi: 10.7759/cureus.12050.
Over the years, knowledge regarding the natural history of Chiari malformation type I (CM-I) has improved. However, there are still uncertainties in the literature regarding asymptomatic and oligosymptomatic patients with CM-I. We performed a literature review in order to determine the natural history of CM-I in symptomatic patients who were not operated and in asymptomatic adult patients. Among symptomatic patients, the most frequent symptom was headache (77%). Cough-related headache alone (34%), migraine-related headache alone (21.4%), and both cough- and migraine-related headaches (21.8%) were the most prevalent forms of headache. Some symptoms improved more effectively with surgical treatment options; cough-related headaches improved by 95% following surgery and by 40% following conservative treatment. Other headache types improved by 93% and 61.5% following conservative and surgical treatments, respectively. Patients diagnosed with asymptomatic or oligosymptomatic CM-I may improve over time or stabilize with conservative treatment. There is great heterogeneity in the literature regarding the diagnostic criteria for CM-I. Owing to the heterogeneity among the articles identified for this review, there is no consensus regarding the precise indications for surgery in asymptomatic patients. The natural CM-I history in asymptomatic patients reveals a favorable evolution.
多年来,关于I型Chiari畸形(CM-I)自然病史的知识已有进步。然而,文献中对于CM-I无症状和症状轻微的患者仍存在不确定性。我们进行了一项文献综述,以确定未接受手术的有症状患者和无症状成年患者中CM-I的自然病史。在有症状的患者中,最常见的症状是头痛(77%)。仅与咳嗽相关的头痛(34%)、仅与偏头痛相关的头痛(21.4%)以及与咳嗽和偏头痛均相关的头痛(21.8%)是最常见的头痛形式。一些症状通过手术治疗方案改善得更有效;与咳嗽相关的头痛在手术后改善了95%,在保守治疗后改善了40%。其他类型的头痛在保守治疗和手术后分别改善了61.5%和93%。被诊断为无症状或症状轻微的CM-I患者可能会随着时间推移而改善或通过保守治疗保持稳定。关于CM-I的诊断标准,文献中存在很大的异质性。由于本次综述所纳入文章之间的异质性,对于无症状患者手术的确切指征尚无共识。无症状患者中CM-I的自然病史显示出良好的演变情况。