Schoenberg Markus Bo, Anger Hubertus Johann Wolfgang, Bucher Julian Nikolaus, Denk Gerald, De Toni Enrico Narciso, Seidensticker Max, Andrassy Joachim, Angele Martin Kurt, Werner Jens, Guba Markus Otto
Department of General, Visceral, and Transplantation Surgery, Ludwig-Maximilians-University Munich, Munich, Germany.
Medical Department II, Ludwig-Maximilians-University Munich, Munich, Germany.
Visc Med. 2020 Dec;36(6):506-515. doi: 10.1159/000506752. Epub 2020 Mar 20.
Current practice to only prioritize hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) that fulfill the Milan criteria (IN) is changing, since it causes the exclusion of patients who could benefit from liver transplantation. To select patients outside MC (OUT) for transplantation, we implemented extended selection criteria without up-front morphometric restrictions containing surrogate parameters of tumor biology.
OUT patients were considered without restrictions of morphometrics and received locoregional treatment after interdisciplinary consultation. Our dynamic selection criteria for OUT patients required (IN): (1) treatment response over (2) at least 6 months and (3) alpha-fetoprotein ≤400 ng/mL over the entire evaluation period. Patients with IN tumors served as control and internal validation cohort.
31 of 170 liver transplant candidates were OUT. Of these, 8 dropped out. The remaining 23 patients met the selection criteria and underwent transplantation. Recurrence-free survival was higher in patients transplanted IN compared to those OUT IN (92.2% vs. 70.8%; = 0.026) after 5 years of follow-up. Overall survival showed no significant difference ( = 0.552). With dynamic selection of transplant candidates, recurrence could also be predicted for the IN patients as internal validation cohort (c-index: 0.896; CI 0.588-0.981, = 0.005).
Dynamic selection criteria for the stratification of patients with OUT HCCs is feasible and allows for excellent long-term results and acceptable tumor recurrence rates comparable to IN patients.
目前仅对符合米兰标准(IN)的肝细胞癌(HCC)进行优先排序的做法正在改变,因为这会导致一些可能从肝移植中获益的患者被排除在外。为了筛选出米兰标准以外(OUT)的患者进行移植,我们实施了扩展选择标准,该标准没有预先设定的形态学限制,而是包含肿瘤生物学的替代参数。
对OUT患者不设形态学限制,并在多学科会诊后给予局部区域治疗。我们针对OUT患者的动态选择标准要求(IN):(1)治疗反应持续(2)至少6个月,且(3)在整个评估期内甲胎蛋白≤400 ng/mL。符合IN标准的肿瘤患者作为对照和内部验证队列。
170例肝移植候选者中有31例为OUT患者。其中,8例退出。其余23例患者符合选择标准并接受了移植。随访5年后,IN组移植患者的无复发生存率高于OUT组(92.2%对70.8%;P = 0.026)。总生存率无显著差异(P = 0.552)。通过对移植候选者进行动态选择,也可以对作为内部验证队列的IN组患者的复发情况进行预测(c指数:0.896;可信区间0.588 - 0.981,P = 0.005)。
对OUT HCC患者进行分层的动态选择标准是可行的,并且能带来出色的长期结果以及与IN组患者相当的可接受肿瘤复发率。