Armon Shunit, Benyamini Yael, Grisaru-Granovsky Sorina, Avitan Tehila
Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Shaare Zedek Medical Center, Affiliated to the Hebrew University Jerusalem, 12 Shmuel Bait St., POB 3235, 91031 Jerusalem, Israel.
Bob Shapell School of Social Work, Tel Aviv University, Tel Aviv, Israel.
Med Sci Educ. 2021 Jan 9;31(2):457-461. doi: 10.1007/s40670-020-01181-y. eCollection 2021 Apr.
The Covid-19 pandemic and social distancing resulted in the need for an immediate transition of all medical education to online education with a concern that such a pandemic might recur.
To assess the feasibility of an online clinical rotation in Obstetrics and Gynecology during the Covid-19 pandemic and to identify effective pedagogical modalities as well as obstacles to online learning.
A questionnaire was sent to the students and staff at the end of the 3-week online rotation. The online curriculum included synchronous learning such as problem-based learning, video demonstrations and discussions, as well as asynchronous pre-recorded lectures. Questions addressed expectations, previous experience, difficulties encountered, effectiveness of different types of pedagogy, and willingness to participate in online education in the future.
We received 27 completed questionnaires, 77% response rate. Overall course rating was 4.14/5 from the students and 3.38/5 from the staff. Previous experience in online education had a positive correlation with higher overall course evaluations; however, low expectations of effectiveness of online learning prior to the course did not correlate with the overall course rate. Challenges identified were absence of bedside teaching and lack of feedback. Effective pedagogical modules were problem-based learning and videos. Additionally, 72% stated that online learning should be part of the formal curriculum.
Further research into tele-teaching should be part of medical school strategic plan to ensure meaningful learning in these emerging modalities not limited to exceptional situations such as pandemics.
The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s40670-020-01181-y.
新冠疫情及社交距离措施导致所有医学教育需立即转向在线教育,同时担心此类疫情可能再次发生。
评估新冠疫情期间妇产科在线临床轮转的可行性,确定有效的教学模式以及在线学习的障碍。
在为期3周的在线轮转结束时,向学生和工作人员发放了问卷。在线课程包括基于问题的学习、视频演示和讨论等同步学习,以及异步预录制讲座。问题涉及期望、以往经验、遇到的困难、不同教学类型的有效性,以及未来参与在线教育的意愿。
我们收到了27份完整问卷,回复率为77%。学生对课程的总体评分是4.14/5,工作人员的评分是3.38/5。以往的在线教育经验与更高的课程总体评价呈正相关;然而,课程开始前对在线学习效果的低期望与课程总体评分无关。确定的挑战是缺乏床边教学和反馈。有效的教学模块是基于问题的学习和视频。此外,72%的人表示在线学习应成为正式课程的一部分。
对远程教学的进一步研究应成为医学院战略计划的一部分,以确保在这些新兴模式中实现有意义的学习,而不仅限于疫情等特殊情况。
在线版本包含可在10.1007/s40670-020-01181-y获取的补充材料。