Division of Health Research, Faculty of Health and Medicine, Lancaster University, Lancaster, LA1 4YT, UK.
BMC Neurol. 2021 Jan 22;21(1):34. doi: 10.1186/s12883-021-02062-6.
The communication of a life-changing diagnosis can be a difficult task for doctors with potential long-term effects on patient outcomes. Although several studies have addressed the experiences of individuals with motor neurodegenerative diseases in receiving this diagnosis, a significant research gap exists regarding professionals' perspectives, especially in the UK. This study aimed to assess UK neurologists' current practice and perspectives on delivering the diagnosis of a motor neurodegenerative disease, explore different aspects of the process and detail the potential challenges professionals might face.
We conducted an anonymised online survey with 44 questions, grouped into four sections; basic demographic information, current practice, the experience of breaking bad news and education and training needs.
Forty-nine professionals completed the survey. Overall, participants seemed to meet the setting-related standards of good practice; however, they also acknowledged the difficulty of this aspect of their clinical work, with about half of participants (46.5%) reporting moderate levels of stress while breaking bad news. Patients' relatives were not always included in diagnostic consultations and participants were more reluctant to promote a sense of optimism to patients with poorer prognosis. Although professionals reported spending a mean of around 30-40 min for the communication of these diagnoses, a significant proportion of participants (21-39%) reported significantly shorter consultation times, highlighting organisational issues related to lack of capacity. Finally, the majority of participants (75.5%) reported not following any specific guidelines or protocols but indicated their interest in receiving further training in breaking bad news (78.5%).
This was the first UK survey to address neurologists' practice and experiences in communicating these diagnoses. Although meeting basic standards of good practice was reported by most professionals, we identified several areas of improvement. These included spending enough time to deliver the diagnosis appropriately, including patients' relatives as a standard, promoting a sense of hope and responding to professionals' training needs regarding breaking bad news.
对于医生来说,传达改变生活的诊断结果可能是一项艰巨的任务,这可能会对患者的预后产生长期影响。尽管有几项研究已经探讨了患有运动神经退行性疾病的个体在接受该诊断时的经历,但关于专业人员观点的研究仍存在很大空白,特别是在英国。本研究旨在评估英国神经病学家在传达运动神经退行性疾病诊断方面的当前实践和观点,探讨这一过程的不同方面,并详细说明专业人员可能面临的潜在挑战。
我们进行了一项匿名在线调查,共有 44 个问题,分为四个部分;基本人口统计学信息、当前实践、打破坏消息的经验以及教育和培训需求。
49 名专业人员完成了调查。总体而言,参与者似乎符合实践相关的良好实践标准;然而,他们也承认这是他们临床工作的困难方面,大约一半的参与者(46.5%)在传达坏消息时报告了中度压力。患者的亲属并不总是被纳入诊断咨询中,参与者更不愿意向预后较差的患者传达乐观情绪。尽管专业人员报告说,他们平均花 30-40 分钟左右的时间来传达这些诊断,但相当一部分参与者(21-39%)报告说咨询时间明显缩短,突出了与能力不足相关的组织问题。最后,大多数参与者(75.5%)表示没有遵循任何特定的指南或方案,但表示有兴趣接受进一步的坏消息传达培训(78.5%)。
这是第一项针对英国神经病学家传达这些诊断的实践和经验的调查。尽管大多数专业人员报告说达到了良好实践的基本标准,但我们发现了几个需要改进的领域。这些领域包括花费足够的时间适当地传达诊断结果,包括将患者的亲属纳入标准,增强希望感,并满足专业人员在坏消息传达方面的培训需求。