Turkmen Buse, Eskin Bacaksiz Feride
Florence Nightingale Faculty of Nursing, Istanbul University Cerrahpasa, Istanbul, Turkey.
Koc University Hospital, Istanbul, Turkey.
J Nurs Manag. 2021 Jul;29(5):1275-1283. doi: 10.1111/jonm.13266. Epub 2021 Feb 16.
To analyse the glass elevator in nursing, evaluating this concept within the conceptual context of nurse managers' perceptions of gender.
Glass elevator is defined as the rapid promotion of men to upper positions in certain professions in which women comprise the majority, such as nursing.
Data were collected from 134 nurse managers. Participants selected one of four resumes belonging to four virtual candidates for an open management position. They, then completed the Perception of Gender Scale.
Nurse managers mostly selected men among the four candidates submitted to them for promotion to upper positions. None of the nurse managers' characteristics caused a statistically significant difference regarding the gender of the candidate they selected. No statistically significant difference was found between the perception of gender scores of those who selected female or male candidates.
Men are two times more likely to be selected than women when selecting candidates for promotion with the same qualifications. This was not caused by the decision-makers' or nurse managers' personal and professional characteristics nor their perceptions on gender.
The psychological mechanisms that operate the 'glass elevator' in favour of men should be analysed in greater depth.
分析护理领域中的“玻璃电梯”现象,在护士长对性别的认知这一概念背景下评估这一概念。
“玻璃电梯”被定义为在女性占多数的某些职业(如护理行业)中男性迅速晋升到高层职位的现象。
从134名护士长处收集数据。参与者从属于四个虚拟候选人的四份简历中选择一份以竞争一个开放的管理职位。然后,他们完成了性别认知量表。
护士长在提交给他们晋升到高层职位的四名候选人中大多选择男性。护士长的任何特征在他们所选候选人的性别方面均未造成统计学上的显著差异。在选择女性或男性候选人的人的性别认知得分之间未发现统计学上的显著差异。
在选择具有相同资质的晋升候选人时,男性被选中的可能性是女性的两倍。这并非由决策者或护士长的个人及职业特征,也非他们对性别的认知所导致。
应更深入地分析有利于男性的“玻璃电梯”运作的心理机制。