Hanahoe Margaret
National Maternity Hospital, Dublin, Ireland.
Eur J Midwifery. 2020 Mar 31;4:7. doi: 10.18332/ejm/119164. eCollection 2020.
Midwifery-led care is recognised as the best choice of maternity care for low-risk women. Robson's Ten Group Classification System (TGCS) is an internationally recognised audit tool, however there is no midwifery-led service presenting their statistics in this way. The objective of this study was to analyse caesarean section rates for the women attending midwifery-led care at the National Maternity Hospital Dublin, Ireland, using the Robson TGCS.
This is a retrospective study of electronic records for a total of 1097 women who were booked to attend the community midwife team in the National Maternity Hospital, during 2016 and 2017.
The rate of caesarean section in low-risk nulliparous women (Robson Group 1) was under 6%, without affecting the perinatal outcome. The induction rate in nulliparous women (Group 2) was 36%, less than the national average the cesarean rates were quadruple in this group.
Low-risk women who attend midwifery-led services, have a low caesarean section rate in this study. This was achieved with continuity of care, good antenatal preparation, and support throughout labour and birth by a dedicated team of midwives. Outcomes can only be truly compared if we use the same criteria to measure them. The TGCS demonstrates the effectiveness of midwifery-led care.
由助产士主导的护理模式被认为是低风险孕妇最佳的孕产护理选择。罗布森十组分类系统(TGCS)是一种国际认可的审计工具,然而目前尚无采用这种方式呈现统计数据的由助产士主导的服务。本研究的目的是使用罗布森TGCS分析在爱尔兰都柏林国家妇产医院接受助产士主导护理的女性的剖宫产率。
这是一项对2016年至2017年期间在国家妇产医院预约由社区助产士团队护理的1097名女性的电子记录进行的回顾性研究。
低风险初产妇(罗布森第1组)的剖宫产率低于6%,且未影响围产期结局。初产妇(第2组)的引产率为36%,低于全国平均水平,该组的剖宫产率是全国平均水平的四倍。
在本研究中,接受助产士主导服务的低风险女性剖宫产率较低。这是通过持续护理、良好的产前准备以及由专业助产士团队在整个分娩过程中提供支持来实现的。只有当我们使用相同的标准来衡量时,结果才能真正进行比较。TGCS证明了助产士主导护理的有效性。