Faculty of Medicine, McGill University, Montreal, QC, Canada.
Department of Computer Science, McGill University, Montreal, QC, Canada.
Graefes Arch Clin Exp Ophthalmol. 2021 Mar;259(3):733-744. doi: 10.1007/s00417-021-05085-4. Epub 2021 Feb 3.
The COVID-19 pandemic increased the gender gap in academic publishing. This study assesses COVID-19's impact on ophthalmology gender authorship distribution and compares the gender authorship proportion of COVID-19 ophthalmology-related articles to previous ophthalmology articles.
This cohort study includes authors listed in all publications related to ophthalmology in the COVID-19 Open Research Dataset and CDC COVID-19 research database. Articles from 65 ophthalmology journals from January to July 2020 were selected. All previous articles published in the same journals were extracted from PubMed. Gender-API determined authors' gender.
Out of 119,457 COVID-19-related articles, we analyzed 528 ophthalmology-related articles written by 2518 authors. Women did not exceed 40% in any authorship positions and were most likely to be middle, first, and finally, last authors. The proportions of women in all authorship positions from the 2020 COVID-19 group (29.6% first, 31.5% middle, 22.1% last) are significantly lower compared to the predicted 2020 data points (37.4% first, 37.0% middle, 27.6% last) (p < .01). The gap between the proportion of female authors in COVID-19 ophthalmology research and the 2020 ophthalmology-predicted proportion (based on 2002-2019 data) is 6.1% for overall authors, 7.8% for first authors, and 5.5% for last and middle authors. The 2020 COVID-19 authorship group (1925 authors) was also compared to the 2019 group (33,049 authors) based on journal category (clinical/basic science research, general/subspecialty ophthalmology, journal impact factor).
COVID-19 amplified the authorship gender gap in ophthalmology. When compared to previous years, there was a greater decrease in women's than men's academic productivity.
COVID-19 大流行增加了学术出版领域的性别差距。本研究评估了 COVID-19 对眼科学术作者署名分布的影响,并将 COVID-19 相关眼科学术文章的性别作者比例与以往的眼科学术文章进行了比较。
本队列研究纳入了 COVID-19 开放研究数据集和 CDC COVID-19 研究数据库中所有与眼科学相关出版物的作者。从 2020 年 1 月至 7 月,选择了 65 种眼科期刊的文章。从 PubMed 中提取了同一期刊发表的所有以前的文章。Gender-API 确定了作者的性别。
在 119457 篇与 COVID-19 相关的文章中,我们分析了 528 篇由 2518 位作者撰写的眼科相关文章。在任何作者职位中,女性都没有超过 40%,而且最有可能担任中级、第一和最后作者。2020 年 COVID-19 组中所有作者职位(第一作者 29.6%,中级作者 31.5%,最后作者 22.1%)中女性的比例明显低于预测的 2020 年数据点(第一作者 37.4%,中级作者 37.0%,最后作者 27.6%)(p<.01)。COVID-19 眼科研究中女性作者的比例与基于 2002-2019 年数据的 2020 年眼科预测比例之间存在 6.1%的差距,第一作者之间的差距为 7.8%,最后和中级作者之间的差距为 5.5%。根据期刊类别(临床/基础科学研究、一般/专科眼科、期刊影响因子),还将 2020 年 COVID-19 作者组(1925 位作者)与 2019 年作者组(33049 位作者)进行了比较。
COVID-19 加剧了眼科学术领域的作者性别差距。与前几年相比,女性的学术生产力下降幅度大于男性。