Calasanti Toni, Carr Dawn, Homan Patricia, Coan Victoria
Department of Sociology, Virginia Tech, Blacksburg, Virginia, USA.
Department of Sociology, Florida State University, Tallahassee, Florida, USA.
Gerontologist. 2021 Nov 15;61(8):1277-1286. doi: 10.1093/geront/gnab015.
Recent research on life satisfaction in retirement explores gender differences but yields inconsistent patterns and does not consider gendered sources of satisfaction. We use a gender relations framework to examine whether women and men experience different changes in life satisfaction with retirement, and whether observed differences are a consequence of different assessments of the leisure, family, and financial situations that characterize their post-retirement lives.
We use longitudinal data drawn from men and women in the Health and Retirement Study who transitioned into retirement between ages 62 and 72 for the first time between 2008 and 2016 (N = 593). We employ ordinary least squares regression and mediation tests to assess gender differences in overall and domain-specific life satisfaction (i.e., leisure, family, finances).
Men reported increased life satisfaction following retirement, but women did not. No gender differences related to leisure or family life post-retirement emerged. Gender was associated with post-retirement satisfaction with finances (p < .001), with men reporting higher financial satisfaction. Mediation models confirmed a gender disparity in overall life satisfaction mediated by satisfaction with finances post-retirement (p < .01), explaining approximately one-third of the disparity.
This study shows men derive greater improvements in life satisfaction in association with retirement than do women, and some of this disparity relates to women's lower satisfaction with their finances. These findings should caution policy-makers from assuming how women's increased labor force participation influences financial security in retirement, and encourage scholars to consider how gender influences subjective assessments of later life.
近期关于退休生活满意度的研究探讨了性别差异,但结果模式并不一致,且未考虑满意度的性别化来源。我们运用性别关系框架来检验男性和女性在退休后生活满意度上是否经历了不同变化,以及观察到的差异是否源于对其退休后生活所特有的休闲、家庭和财务状况的不同评估。
我们使用了来自健康与退休研究中62至72岁之间在2008年至2016年间首次退休的男性和女性的纵向数据(N = 593)。我们采用普通最小二乘法回归和中介检验来评估总体和特定领域生活满意度(即休闲、家庭、财务)方面的性别差异。
男性报告退休后生活满意度有所提高,但女性没有。退休后在休闲或家庭生活方面未出现性别差异。性别与退休后财务满意度相关(p <.001),男性报告的财务满意度更高。中介模型证实了退休后财务满意度介导的总体生活满意度存在性别差异(p <.01),解释了约三分之一的差异。
本研究表明,与女性相比,男性在退休后生活满意度方面的提升更大,这种差异部分与女性对财务状况较低的满意度有关。这些发现应提醒政策制定者不要想当然地认为女性劳动力参与率的提高如何影响退休后的财务安全,并鼓励学者考虑性别如何影响对晚年生活的主观评估。