Department of Energy and Environment, TERI School of Advanced Studies, New Delhi, India.
Department of Civil Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology, New Delhi, India.
Environ Sci Pollut Res Int. 2021 Jun;28(22):28391-28406. doi: 10.1007/s11356-021-12383-1. Epub 2021 Feb 4.
The present study investigated the variation in leachate pollution index (LPI) of four municipal solid waste (MSW) dumping sites: non-engineered (Okhla, Ghazipur, Bhalswa) and engineered (Narela-Bawana) of Delhi, India. A review of 142 screened studies from Google Scholar database was done for synthesis of information on LPI parameters. Further, the rate constant determination and human health risk assessment for various leachate parameters was done. Results showed the following LPI trends: Okhla landfill: irregular with exceedance to threshold value; Bhalswa landfill: exponential increase; and Narela-Bawana landfill: linear increase. Parameters such as pH, dissolved solids, copper, nickel, zinc, and chromium of Bhalswa landfill, exhibited an exponential decay with LPI variation. Whereas, for Narela-Bawana's leachate BOD and COD parameters, an exponential decay in LPI vs zinc and linear increase for LPI vs lead was observed. For all dumping sites, a positive correlation was observed between heavy metals and LPI. In case of human health risk assessment, order of oral risk posed by Okhla's metals was cadmium > chromium > nickel > lead, with maximum hazard quotient (HQ) of 1.61 for cadmium. For Ghazipur and Bhalswa landfills, cancer risk values for both adult and child sub-populations were observed to be maximum for cadmium followed by nickel, chromium, and minimum for lead. For Narela-Bawana landfill, the order of cancer risk was as follows: chromium > nickel > lead. HQ for Pb-contaminated groundwater exceeded the threshold limit in Ghazipur and Bhalswa landfills. For dermal groundwater exposure, cadmium for Okhla (adult 2.3 × 10 and child 1.4 × 10), Ghazipur (adult 9 × 10 and child 5.2 × 10), and Bhalswa (adult 1.5 × 10 and child 8.6 × 10) was observed to have maximum cancer risk. The analyzed year-wise LPI trend, calculated rate constants, and human health risk values from present study provide a basis to waste managers and regulators for understanding various waste sources.
本研究调查了印度德里的四个城市固体废物(MSW)倾倒场(非工程化的(Okhla、Ghazipur、Bhalswa)和工程化的(Narela-Bawana))渗滤液污染指数(LPI)的变化。通过 Google Scholar 数据库对 142 项筛选研究进行了综述,以综合 LPI 参数信息。此外,还对各种渗滤液参数的速率常数确定和人体健康风险评估进行了研究。结果表明,LPI 呈现以下趋势:Okhla 垃圾填埋场:不规则,超过阈值;Bhalswa 垃圾填埋场:指数增长;Narela-Bawana 垃圾填埋场:线性增长。Bhalswa 垃圾填埋场的 pH 值、溶解固体、铜、镍、锌和铬等参数与 LPI 变化呈指数衰减。而对于 Narela-Bawana 垃圾渗滤液的 BOD 和 COD 参数,LPI 与锌呈指数衰减,LPI 与铅呈线性增长。对于所有倾倒场,重金属与 LPI 之间存在正相关关系。在人体健康风险评估方面,Okhla 金属的口服风险顺序为镉>铬>镍>铅,镉的最大危害商(HQ)为 1.61。对于 Ghazipur 和 Bhalswa 垃圾填埋场,对于成人和儿童亚人群,镉的癌症风险值最大,其次是镍、铬,铅的风险值最小。对于 Narela-Bawana 垃圾填埋场,癌症风险的顺序如下:铬>镍>铅。Pb 污染地下水的 HQ 在 Ghazipur 和 Bhalswa 垃圾填埋场超过了阈值限制。对于皮肤地下水暴露,Okhla(成人 2.3×10 和儿童 1.4×10)、Ghazipur(成人 9×10 和儿童 5.2×10)和 Bhalswa(成人 1.5×10 和儿童 8.6×10)的镉具有最大的癌症风险。本研究分析了逐年的 LPI 趋势、计算的速率常数和人体健康风险值,为垃圾管理者和监管机构提供了了解各种废物来源的基础。