Graduate School of Arts and Sciences, Brandeis University, Waltham, MA, USA.
Division of Pulmonary Medicine, Boston Children's Hospital, Boston, MA, USA.
J Genet Couns. 2021 Jun;30(3):813-827. doi: 10.1002/jgc4.1381. Epub 2021 Feb 6.
Racial and ethnic minority graduate students in a variety of academic and professional disciplines have been reported to experience microaggressions and feelings of isolation during the course of their training. The purpose of this constructivist grounded theory study was to characterize the training experiences of genetic counseling students who identify as racial or ethnic minorities. The goal of enhancing racial and ethnic diversity has been discussed for decades within the genetic counseling profession, but the actual training experience of underrepresented minorities has yet to be fully explored. We conducted 13 videoconference focus groups with 32 recent graduates of genetic counseling training programs who identify as racial or ethnic minorities. This paper presents results from three of the thematic categories identified in that larger study: Participants' interactions with classmates, Sense of belonging in the GC profession, and Available or desired supports. Participants reported experiencing negative interactions within their training program, during supervised clinical rotations, and at professional events; negative interactions included comments suggesting they did not belong in the United States, being confused with another non-white classmate, and intrusive questions or assumptions about their family, culture, or religion that were not similarly directed at white classmates. Trainees who were Muslim or Black/African American reported feeling particularly isolated by these incidents. Participants reported that they sought support from a variety of sources following negative experiences. Non-minority program faculty were perceived as able to offer listening or action but not understanding or guidance, which were perceived as more likely to be available from individuals who identify as racial or ethnic minorities. Results of this exploratory study suggest the need for training programs to ensure that appropriate supports are available to minority students, including diverse faculty and staff and non-program resources.
在各种学术和专业学科中,少数民族和族裔研究生在培训过程中经历过微侵犯和孤立感。本建构主义扎根理论研究的目的是描述少数民族遗传咨询师培训经历的特点。数十年来,遗传咨询专业一直讨论增强种族和族裔多样性的目标,但代表性不足的少数群体的实际培训经历尚未得到充分探讨。我们对 32 名最近毕业的少数民族遗传咨询师培训项目学生进行了 13 次视频会议焦点小组讨论。本文介绍了从更大研究中确定的三个主题类别中的结果:参与者与同学的互动、在遗传咨询专业中的归属感以及现有的或所需的支持。参与者报告说,他们在培训计划中、监督临床轮转期间和专业活动中经历了负面互动;负面互动包括暗示他们不属于美国的言论、被与另一位非白人同学混淆、以及对他们的家庭、文化或宗教的侵入性问题或假设,这些问题并没有同样针对白人同学。穆斯林或非裔美国/非裔遗传咨询学员报告说,他们特别因这些事件而感到孤立。参与者报告说,他们在经历负面事件后会从各种来源寻求支持。少数族裔项目的非少数族裔教职员工被认为能够提供倾听或行动,但不能提供理解或指导,而这些被认为更有可能从认同少数民族的人那里获得。这项探索性研究的结果表明,培训计划需要确保为少数族裔学生提供适当的支持,包括多样化的教职员工和非项目资源。