Agashe Mandar V, Pinto Deepika A, Vaidya Sandeep
Agashe's Paediatric Super Speciality Clinic, Kohinoor city phase 2, Kirol road, kurla west 16094, Mumbai, 400070 India.
Pinnacle Ortho Centre, Thane, India.
Indian J Orthop. 2020 Jun 3;55(1):100-108. doi: 10.1007/s43465-020-00156-w. eCollection 2021 Feb.
Modified Dunn procedure has become popular for the treatment of severe cases of slipped capital femoral epiphysis (SCFE). We assessed the outcomes in a consecutive series of thirty Indian adolescents treated by the modified Dunn procedure.
All patients treated by the modified Dunn procedure by a single senior Paediatric Orthopaedic surgeon over six years were retrospectively reviewed. Only moderate and severe slips undergoing modified Dunn procedure were included. Clinical records and radiographs were reviewed to obtain demographic information; to classify the slips by duration of symptoms, severity and physeal stability; and to assess the outcomes by Harris Hip Score, radiological changes and rate of complications.
Thirty consecutive hips with 19 stable and 11 unstable slips were included. Mean age was 13.05 years, 25 boys and 5 girls; six were acute slips, six chronic and eighteen acute-on-chronic. There were 20 moderate and 10 severe slips. Slip angle correction was on average 43.63° ± 8.42° ( < 0.001). At a mean follow-up of 25.36 months, the slip angle averaged 9.9° ± 3.78°, and alpha angle was 33.63° ± 4.14. The average Harris Hip Score was 81.833 ± 7.12 points, with six excellent, 17 good, six fair and one poor result. Osteonecrosis occurred in two hips (6.6%). One hip had post-operative subluxation which was corrected.
This study adds to the evidence that the modified Dunn procedure is safe, reliable and reproducible. It should be the first choice for the treatment of moderate and severe SCFE.
改良邓恩手术已广泛应用于重度股骨头骨骺滑脱(SCFE)病例的治疗。我们评估了连续30例接受改良邓恩手术治疗的印度青少年患者的治疗效果。
回顾性分析一位资深小儿骨科医生在六年内采用改良邓恩手术治疗的所有患者。仅纳入接受改良邓恩手术的中度和重度滑脱患者。查阅临床记录和X线片以获取人口统计学信息;根据症状持续时间、严重程度和骨骺稳定性对滑脱进行分类;并通过Harris髋关节评分、影像学变化和并发症发生率评估治疗效果。
连续纳入30例髋关节,其中19例为稳定型滑脱,11例为不稳定型滑脱。平均年龄为13.05岁,男性25例,女性5例;急性滑脱6例,慢性滑脱6例,急性转为慢性滑脱18例。中度滑脱20例,重度滑脱10例。滑脱角平均矫正43.63°±8.42°(<0.001)。平均随访25.36个月时,滑脱角平均为9.9°±3.78°,α角为33.63°±4.14°。Harris髋关节评分平均为81.833±7.12分,其中优6例,良17例,可6例,差1例。2例髋关节发生骨坏死(6.6%)。1例髋关节术后出现半脱位,已得到矫正。
本研究进一步证明改良邓恩手术安全、可靠且可重复。它应成为治疗中度和重度SCFE的首选方法。