Clinical Pharmacy Department, Faculty of Pharmacy, Beni-Suef University, Beni-Suef, Egypt.
Clement Clarke International Ltd, Harlow, UK.
Int J Clin Pract. 2021 Jun;75(6):e14088. doi: 10.1111/ijcp.14088. Epub 2021 Feb 20.
Although metered-dose inhalers (pMDI) therapy is convenient and widely prescribed, its use usually results in repetitive inhalation technique errors. One of the most repetitive errors is inhaling too fast through the pMDI. The present study aimed to evaluate the effect of Clip-tone along with smartphone visual feedback application on the subject's inhalation time.
Two hundred subjects were included in the study. They were randomised into four groups. Group 1 received only verbal counselling; group 2 received verbal counselling with resistance (a modified Clip-tone that does not produce whistle attached to their pMDI); group 3 received verbal counselling plus whistle (as audio feedback) from ordinary Clip-tone and group 4 received verbal counselling plus audio feedback (whistle) from Clip-tone and visual feedback (smartphone application). Inhalation time through the pMDI for each subject was recorded three times and inter and intra-subjects variations were calculated.
Verbal counselling plus audio feedback and verbal counselling plus audio and visual feedbacks groups had 45/50 (90%) and 37/50 (74%) subjects respectively, having correct inhalation flow (inhaling at between 3 to 7 seconds). Verbal counselling plus audio feedback and verbal counselling plus audio and visual feedbacks groups' inter and intra-subjects variations were lower than that of verbal counselling and verbal counselling with resistance groups which had 28/50 (52%) and 20/50 (40%) subjects respectively, with inhalation time between 3 and 7 seconds.
Providing audio feedback by the Clip-tone along with smartphone visual feedback application maintained the deep and slow inhalation through pMDI much better compared to verbal counselling only. We recommend the patients to take all their inhaled doses using pMDI attached to a training device like Clip-tone along with a smartphone visual feedback application for optimisation of the aerosol delivery from the pMDI.
尽管定量吸入器(pMDI)治疗方便且广泛应用,但患者通常会重复出现吸入技术错误。其中最常见的错误之一是通过 pMDI 过快地吸气。本研究旨在评估 Clip-tone 联合智能手机视觉反馈应用对患者吸气时间的影响。
本研究纳入了 200 名受试者,将其随机分为四组。第 1 组仅接受口头咨询;第 2 组接受口头咨询加阻力(一种不发出哨声的改良 Clip-tone,连接到他们的 pMDI 上);第 3 组接受口头咨询加普通 Clip-tone 的哨声(音频反馈);第 4 组接受口头咨询加 Clip-tone 的哨声和视觉反馈(智能手机应用)。记录每位受试者通过 pMDI 吸入的时间,重复测量 3 次,并计算组内和组间变异。
口头咨询加音频反馈和口头咨询加音频和视觉反馈组分别有 45/50(90%)和 37/50(74%)的受试者正确吸气(吸气时间在 3 到 7 秒之间)。口头咨询加音频反馈和口头咨询加音频和视觉反馈组的组内和组间变异均低于仅接受口头咨询的组,该组有 28/50(52%)和 20/50(40%)的受试者吸气时间在 3 到 7 秒之间。
Clip-tone 提供的音频反馈以及智能手机视觉反馈应用能更好地维持通过 pMDI 的深而慢的吸气,而不仅仅是口头咨询。我们建议患者在使用 pMDI 时,将其与训练设备(如 Clip-tone)以及智能手机视觉反馈应用一起使用,以优化 pMDI 的气溶胶输送。