Andrzej Frycz Modrzewski Krakow University, Gustawa Herlinga-Grudzinskiego 1, 30-705 Krakow, Poland.
Harefield Hospital, Royal Brompton & Harefield NHS Foundation Trust, Hill End Road, UB9 6JH, London, UK.
Eur Heart J Acute Cardiovasc Care. 2021 Mar 5;10(1):94-101. doi: 10.1093/ehjacc/zuaa027.
The implementation of the 2013 European Society of Cardiology (ESC) Core Curriculum guidelines for acute cardiovascular care (acc) training among European countries is unknown. We aimed to evaluate the current status of acc training among cardiology trainees and young cardiologists (<40 years) from ESC countries.
The survey (March-July 2019) asked about details of cardiology training, self-confidence in acc technical and non-technical skills, access to training opportunities, and needs for further training in the field. Overall 614 young doctors, 31 (26-43) years old, 55% males were surveyed. Place and duration of acc training differed between countries and between centres in the same country. Although the majority of the respondents (91%) had completed their acc training, the average self-confidence to perform invasive procedures and to manage acc clinical scenarios was low-44% (27.3-70.4). The opportunities for simulation-based learning were scarce-18% (5.8-51.3), as it was previous leadership training (32%) and knowledge about key teamwork principles was poor (48%). The need for further acc training was high-81% (61.9-94.3). Male gender, higher level of training centres, professional qualifications of respondents, longer duration of acc/intensive care training, debriefings, and previous leadership training as well as knowledge about teamwork were related to higher self-confidence in all investigated aspects.
The current cardiology training program is burdened by deficits in acc technical/non-technical skills, substantial variability in programs across ESC countries, and a clear gender-related disparity in outcomes. The forthcoming ESC Core Curriculum for General Cardiology is expected to address these deficiencies.
欧洲心脏病学会(ESC)2013 年急性心血管护理(ACC)培训核心课程指南在欧洲各国的实施情况尚不清楚。我们旨在评估欧洲 ESC 国家的心脏病学受训者和年轻心脏病专家(<40 岁)目前的 ACC 培训状况。
这项调查(2019 年 3 月至 7 月)询问了心脏病学培训的详细信息、对 ACC 技术和非技术技能的自信程度、获得培训机会的情况以及该领域进一步培训的需求。共有 614 名年轻医生,年龄 31(26-43)岁,55%为男性接受了调查。ACC 培训的地点和持续时间在国家之间以及同一国家的不同中心之间存在差异。尽管大多数受访者(91%)已经完成了 ACC 培训,但他们进行有创性操作和管理 ACC 临床情况的平均自信程度较低-44%(27.3-70.4)。基于模拟的学习机会很少-18%(5.8-51.3),而之前的领导力培训(32%)和对关键团队合作原则的了解较差(48%)。进一步的 ACC 培训需求很高-81%(61.9-94.3)。男性性别、培训中心的较高水平、受访者的专业资格、ACC/重症监护培训的持续时间较长、汇报和之前的领导力培训以及对团队合作的了解与所有调查方面的更高自信程度相关。
目前的心脏病学培训计划在 ACC 技术/非技术技能方面存在不足,ESC 国家之间的方案存在很大差异,结果明显存在性别差异。即将出台的 ESC 普通心脏病学核心课程有望解决这些不足。