Stein Duker Leah I, Schmidt Anita R, Pham Phung K, Ringold Sofronia M, Nager Alan L
Division of Occupational Science and Occupational Therapy, University of Southern California, Los Angeles, CA, United States.
Division of Emergency and Transport Medicine, Department of Pediatrics, Children's Hospital Los Angeles, Los Angeles, CA, United States.
Front Pediatr. 2021 Jan 5;8:556805. doi: 10.3389/fped.2020.556805. eCollection 2020.
Anxiety and anticipatory stressors are commonly experienced by children visiting the Pediatric Emergency Department (PED), but little research exists that addresses the efficacy of interventions to decrease this stress. This one-sample pretest-postest pilot study gathered preliminary data on the feasibility and effectiveness of utilizing audiobooks to reduce fear and state anxiety in children in the PED. Participants were 131 children in kindergarten through 8th grade ( = 9.4 years, 54% female), triaged urgent or emergent, presenting to the PED. Participants self-reported fear (Children's Fear Scale) and state anxiety (modified State-Trait Anxiety Inventory for Children; mSTAIC) before and after listening to an age-appropriate audiobook (two options). Data regarding patient experience were also collected. Paired samples -test was used to examine pre-post intervention changes in fear and state anxiety. Significant, albeit small, improvements in fear and the mSTAIC states of nervous, calm, happy, and relaxed were found after use of the audiobook (Cohen's = 0.22-0.35). Small, yet significant correlations were found between child age/grade level and improvements in fear and in the mSTAIC states of scared and relaxed, suggesting that the audiobook was more beneficial for older participants. Over 60% of participants liked the audiobook content "a lot" as well as enjoyed listening to the audiobook "a lot." Without prompting, 15% of participants requested to listen to an additional audiobook. Listening to an audiobook is feasible and could be effective in decreasing fear and state anxiety for children during a waiting period in the PED. The technology is low-cost, simple, and portable. The results of this study should be interpreted with prudence due to the lack of a control group and results that, although significant, were modest based on effect size conventions; future studies should explore the impact of audiobooks on patient stress with an expanded sample size and control group.
前往儿科急诊科(PED)就诊的儿童通常会经历焦虑和预期性应激源,但针对减少此类应激的干预措施效果的研究却很少。这项单样本前测-后测试点研究收集了关于利用有声读物减少PED中儿童恐惧和状态焦虑的可行性和有效性的初步数据。参与者为131名幼儿园至八年级的儿童(平均年龄=9.4岁,54%为女性),经分诊为紧急或急症,前往PED就诊。参与者在听适合其年龄的有声读物(两种选择)前后自我报告恐惧(儿童恐惧量表)和状态焦虑(儿童状态-特质焦虑量表修订版;mSTAIC)。还收集了有关患者体验的数据。采用配对样本t检验来检查干预前后恐惧和状态焦虑的变化。使用有声读物后,恐惧以及mSTAIC中紧张、平静、快乐和放松状态有显著改善,尽管改善幅度较小(科恩d值=0.22 - 0.35)。发现儿童年龄/年级水平与恐惧以及mSTAIC中恐惧和放松状态的改善之间存在小而显著的相关性,这表明有声读物对年龄较大的参与者更有益。超过60%的参与者“非常”喜欢有声读物内容,也“非常”喜欢听有声读物。在没有提示的情况下,15%的参与者要求再听一本有声读物。在PED的等待期间,听有声读物是可行的,并且可能有效减少儿童的恐惧和状态焦虑。该技术成本低、简单且便于携带。由于缺乏对照组,且结果虽显著但基于效应量标准较为适度,本研究结果应谨慎解读;未来的研究应通过扩大样本量和设立对照组来探索有声读物对患者应激的影响。