Zhuang Xiaojun, Tian Zhenyi, Li Na, Mao Ren, Li Xiaozhi, Zhao Min, Xiong Shanshan, Zeng Zhirong, Feng Rui, Chen Minhu
Department of Gastroenterology, The First Affiliated Hospital, Sun Yat-sen University, Guangzhou, China.
Front Med (Lausanne). 2021 Jan 28;7:615858. doi: 10.3389/fmed.2020.615858. eCollection 2020.
Gut microbiota recolonization after intestinal resection had been reported to be associated with post-operative recurrence in Crohn's disease (CD). However, the results of different studies are inconsistent and even contradictory. In addition, knowledge on the efficacy of microbial-based therapies in preventing post-operative recurrence of CD is limited. Therefore, the aim of this review was to investigate gut microbiota profiles in patients with CD before and after surgery and evaluate microbial-based therapies in preventing post-operative recurrence. Electronic databases were searched from inception to 31 June 2020 using predefined terms. Studies that investigated gut microbiota pre- and post-intestinal resection, and microbial-based therapies in preventing post-operative recurrence, were eligible. Study quality was assessed using either the Newcastle-Ottawa scale or Jadad scoring system. Twelve studies investigating gut microbiota of CD patients suffering from operation, and other 12 studies evaluating the efficacy of antibiotics and probiotics, were included in our review. The mucosa-associated microbiota in surgical biopsy of CD patients is significantly distinct from that in normal mucosa from healthy subjects. Gut microbiota recolonization following surgery might be associated with post-operative recurrence in CD patients. Furthermore, CD patients with post-operative recurrence presented a gain in pro-inflammatory pathogenic bacteria and a loss in short-chain fatty acid-producing bacteria before and after surgery. However, no consistent bacteria or metabolites were found to predict the post-operative recurrence of CD. Additionally, microbial-based therapies are deficient and present restricted widespread clinical utility due to several deficiencies. Recurrence-associated bacteria observed pre- and post- operation might be promising in preventing the post-operative recurrence of CD. Furthermore, potential microbe biomarkers for predicting subsequent disease recurrence should be validated with larger sample sizes using more rigorous and standardized methodologies.
据报道,肠道切除术后肠道微生物群的重新定殖与克罗恩病(CD)的术后复发有关。然而,不同研究的结果并不一致,甚至相互矛盾。此外,关于基于微生物的疗法在预防CD术后复发方面的疗效的知识有限。因此,本综述的目的是研究CD患者手术前后的肠道微生物群特征,并评估基于微生物的疗法在预防术后复发方面的效果。使用预定义术语从数据库建立至2020年6月31日进行电子数据库检索。研究肠道切除术前和术后的肠道微生物群以及基于微生物的疗法在预防术后复发方面的研究符合要求。使用纽卡斯尔-渥太华量表或雅达评分系统评估研究质量。我们的综述纳入了12项研究CD手术患者肠道微生物群的研究,以及另外12项评估抗生素和益生菌疗效的研究。CD患者手术活检中的黏膜相关微生物群与健康受试者正常黏膜中的微生物群显著不同。手术后肠道微生物群的重新定殖可能与CD患者的术后复发有关。此外,术后复发的CD患者在手术前后促炎病原菌增加,产短链脂肪酸的细菌减少。然而,未发现一致的细菌或代谢产物可预测CD的术后复发。此外,基于微生物的疗法存在缺陷,由于多种不足,其临床应用受到限制。手术前后观察到的与复发相关的细菌可能在预防CD术后复发方面具有前景。此外,用于预测后续疾病复发的潜在微生物生物标志物应使用更严格和标准化的方法,通过更大样本量进行验证。