Maurer Lisa Katharina, Joch Michael, Hegele Mathias, Müller Hermann
Neuromotor Behavior Laboratory, Department of Psychology and Sport Science, Justus Liebig University Giessen, Germany.
Center for Mind, Brain and Behavior, Universities of Marburg and Giessen Giessen, Germany.
J Hum Kinet. 2021 Jan 29;76:67-81. doi: 10.2478/hukin-2020-0087. eCollection 2021 Jan.
The Error-related negativity (Ne/ERN) and the feedback-related negativity (FRN), two event-related potentials in electroencephalogram tracings, have been used to examine error processing in conscious actions. In the classical terminology the Ne/ERN and the FRN are differentiated with respect to whether internal (Ne/ERN) or external (FRN) error information is processed. In motor tasks, however, errors of different types can be made: A wrong action can be selected that is not adequate to achieve the task goal (or action effect), or the correctly selected action can be mis-performed such that the task goal might be missed (movement error). Depending on the motor task and the temporal sequences of these events, internal and external error information can coincide. Hence, a clear distinction of the information source is difficult, and the classical terminology that differentiates the Ne/ERN and the FRN with respect to internal and external error information becomes ambiguous. But, a stronger focus on the characteristics of the definition of "task" and the cause of "errors", as well as on temporal characteristics of event-related potentials with respect to the task action allows separate examination of the processing of movement errors, the processing of the prediction of action effect errors, or the processing of the detection of action effect errors. The present article gives an overview of example studies investigating the Ne/ERN and the FRN in motor tasks, classifies them with respect to action effect errors or movement errors, and proposes updated terminology.
错误相关负波(Ne/ERN)和反馈相关负波(FRN)是脑电图记录中的两种事件相关电位,已被用于研究有意识行动中的错误处理。在经典术语中,Ne/ERN和FRN是根据处理的是内部(Ne/ERN)还是外部(FRN)错误信息来区分的。然而,在运动任务中,可能会出现不同类型的错误:可以选择一个不足以实现任务目标(或动作效果)的错误动作,或者正确选择的动作可能执行错误,从而导致错过任务目标(运动错误)。根据运动任务以及这些事件的时间顺序,内部和外部错误信息可能会重合。因此,很难明确区分信息来源,而根据内部和外部错误信息区分Ne/ERN和FRN的经典术语也变得模糊不清。但是,更关注“任务”定义的特征和“错误”的原因,以及事件相关电位相对于任务动作的时间特征,能够分别研究运动错误的处理、动作效果错误预测的处理或动作效果错误检测的处理。本文概述了在运动任务中研究Ne/ERN和FRN的示例研究,根据动作效果错误或运动错误对它们进行分类,并提出更新的术语。