DeVito Elise E, Weinberger Andrea H, Pang Raina D, Petersen Nicole, Fagle Tessa, Allen Alicia M
Department of Psychiatry, Yale University School of Medicine, New Haven, CT, USA.
Ferkauf Graduate School of Psychology, Yeshiva University, Bronx, New York USA.
Curr Behav Neurosci Rep. 2020 Sep;7(3):109-127. doi: 10.1007/s40473-020-00213-6. Epub 2020 Jul 15.
The goal was to review recent (1/2015-2/2020) evidence of impulsivity as a feature of substance use disorders or use of substances (alcohol, cannabis, nicotine, opioids, stimulants) in males compared to females in terms of: a) impulsivity in substance-using groups (or substance-using compared to control groups), and b) relationship between impulsivity and substance use behavior, clinical severity, or treatment outcomes.
Of 361 papers identified by the searches, 69 met inclusion criteria, and 39 were highlighted for considering sex/gender in relation to impulsivity in substance-using populations. Taken together, findings supported higher impulsivity in males and females who use substances, relative to controls; and higher impulsivity was linked with more substance use/severity in both sex/genders. There were mixed findings regarding male versus female differences in impulsivity among individuals who use substances, or in the magnitude of the relationship between impulsivity and substance use severity.
The current body of evidence does not point to a consistent sex/gender difference in the role of impulsivity within and across substance use disorders. Impulsivity is a clinically-relevant construct for male and female individuals who use substances, across a range of substances.
旨在回顾近期(2015年1月至2020年2月)关于冲动性作为物质使用障碍特征或男性与女性使用物质(酒精、大麻、尼古丁、阿片类药物、兴奋剂)情况的证据,具体涉及:a)物质使用群体中的冲动性(或与对照组相比的物质使用情况),以及b)冲动性与物质使用行为、临床严重程度或治疗结果之间的关系。
在检索到的361篇论文中,69篇符合纳入标准,39篇因考虑了物质使用人群中与冲动性相关的性别因素而被重点提及。综合来看,研究结果支持使用物质的男性和女性相对于对照组具有更高的冲动性;且在两种性别中,更高的冲动性都与更多的物质使用/严重程度相关。关于使用物质个体的冲动性方面的男女差异,或冲动性与物质使用严重程度之间关系的程度,研究结果存在分歧。
目前的证据并未表明在物质使用障碍内部及之间,冲动性的作用存在一致的性别差异。对于使用物质的男性和女性个体而言,冲动性是一个与临床相关的概念,涉及多种物质。