Adam Katherine E, Bruce Ann, Corbishley Alexander
Innogen Institute, Science Technology and Innovation Studies, School of Social and Political Science, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, United Kingdom.
Royal (Dick) School of Veterinary Sciences and the Roslin Institute, University of Edinburgh, Midlothian, United Kingdom.
Front Vet Sci. 2021 Feb 4;8:619889. doi: 10.3389/fvets.2021.619889. eCollection 2021.
Neonatal lamb and calf deaths are a major issue in UK agriculture. Consistent mortality rates over several decades, despite scientific advances, indicate that socioeconomic factors must also be understood and addressed for effective veterinary service delivery to improve lamb and calf survival. This qualitative study utilised semi-structured interviews with vets and farmers to explore the on-farm mechanisms and social context, with a particular focus on the role of the vet, to manage and reduce neonatal losses in beef calves and lambs on British farms. Data were analysed using a realist evaluation framework to assess how the mechanisms and context for veterinary service delivery influence survival as the outcome of interest. A lack of a clear outcome definition of neonatal mortality, and the financial, social and emotional impact of losses on both vets and farmers, are barriers to recording of losses and standardisation of acceptable mortality levels at a population level. Despite this, there appears to be an individual threshold on each farm at which losses become perceived as problematic, and veterinary involvement shifts from preventive to reactive mechanisms for service delivery. The veterinarian-farmer relationship is central to efforts to maximise survival, but the social and economic capital available to farmers influences the quality of this relationship. Health inequalities are well-recognised as an issue in human healthcare and the findings indicate that similar inequalities exist in livestock health systems.
新生羔羊和犊牛死亡是英国农业中的一个主要问题。尽管科学取得了进步,但几十年来死亡率一直居高不下,这表明为了有效提供兽医服务以提高羔羊和犊牛的存活率,还必须了解和解决社会经济因素。这项定性研究通过对兽医和农民进行半结构化访谈,探讨农场层面的机制和社会背景,特别关注兽医的作用,以管理和减少英国农场肉牛犊和羔羊的新生期损失。使用现实主义评估框架对数据进行分析,以评估兽医服务提供的机制和背景如何影响作为关注结果的存活率。缺乏对新生期死亡率的明确结果定义,以及损失对兽医和农民造成的经济、社会和情感影响,是在种群层面记录损失和确定可接受死亡率标准的障碍。尽管如此,每个农场似乎都有一个个体阈值,当损失被视为问题时,兽医的参与就会从预防性机制转向反应性机制。兽医与农民的关系对于实现最大存活率的努力至关重要,但农民可获得的社会和经济资本会影响这种关系的质量。健康不平等在人类医疗保健中是一个公认的问题,研究结果表明,畜牧健康系统中也存在类似的不平等现象。