Antonsen Yngve, Bye Geir
Department of Education, Faculty of Humanities, Social Sciences and Education, UiT The Arctic University of Norway, Tromso, Norway.
NORCE Norwegian Research Centre AS, Tromsø, Norway.
Leadersh Health Serv (Bradf Engl). 2020 Oct 16;33(4):445-460. doi: 10.1108/LHS-04-2020-0020.
This study aims to analyse the line managers and employees' use of lean task boards over time in Norwegian municipalities using action learning theory. The research question was the following: what kind of action learning processes do the line managers and employees' use of the lean task board promote in municipalities' healthcare units?
DESIGN/METHODOLOGY/APPROACH: This qualitative case study data from a Norwegian municipality involved analyses of 750 internal self-recorded logs from task board sessions from 6 different units and 25 semi-structured interviews of managers and employees.
The task board works for line managers to make employees responsible for forwarding ideas, solutions and implementation of new actions. The use of the task boards contributes to systemising work through establishing new routines and improving orderliness at work. The line managers used the task boards as a project management system to track progress in the purchasing of diverse equipment and initiatives to improve professionalism and their units' facilities. The study explains the learning challenges for managers using the lean task board, as the method promotes finding experience-based solutions that do not involve critical reflection and use of theory.
The lean task board is well-suited for managers to promote learning processes that counteract chaos in local healthcare organisations. However, the task board has limitations as a method for improving services amongst healthcare units and for solving difficult problems.
ORIGINALITY/VALUE: The study contributes to understanding how action learning theory can be applied to the analysis of the results of lean task board sessions.
本研究旨在运用行动学习理论,分析挪威各市镇中直线经理和员工对精益任务板的长期使用情况。研究问题如下:直线经理和员工对精益任务板的使用在市镇医疗单位中促进了何种行动学习过程?
设计/方法/途径:本定性案例研究的数据来自挪威的一个市镇,涉及对6个不同单位的750份任务板会议内部自我记录日志的分析,以及对经理和员工的25次半结构化访谈。
任务板有助于直线经理让员工负责提出新行动的想法、解决方案并加以实施。任务板的使用通过建立新的工作流程和提高工作的有序性,有助于使工作系统化。直线经理将任务板用作项目管理系统,以跟踪各种设备采购的进展情况以及提高专业性和单位设施水平的举措。该研究解释了使用精益任务板的经理所面临的学习挑战,因为该方法促进寻找基于经验的解决方案,而不涉及批判性反思和理论的运用。
精益任务板非常适合经理促进学习过程,以应对当地医疗组织中的混乱局面。然而,任务板作为改善医疗单位服务和解决难题的方法存在局限性。
原创性/价值:该研究有助于理解行动学习理论如何应用于分析精益任务板会议的结果。