Graduate Program in Genetics and Molecular Biology, Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul, Porto Alegre, RS, Brazil.
Dermatology Section, Universidade Federal de Ciências da Saúde de Porto Alegre, Porto Alegre, RS, Brazil; Dermatological Pediatrics Section, Hospital da Criança Santo Antônio, Irmandade da Santa Casa de Misericórdia de Porto Alegre, Porto Alegre, RS, Brazil.
An Bras Dermatol. 2021 Mar-Apr;96(2):155-162. doi: 10.1016/j.abd.2020.05.015. Epub 2021 Feb 2.
Epidermolysis bullosa is characterized by cutaneous fragility and blistering. Historically, diagnosis is achieved by immunofluorescence mapping or transmission electron microscopy, both involving biopsy procedures. Genetic analysis, especially through next-generation sequencing, is an important tool for the diagnosis of this disease. In Brazil, access to diagnostic methods is limited, and consequently, most patients do not have an accurate diagnosis. Diagnosis allows the indication of prognosis and genetic counselling of the patient.
To evaluate the cost-effectiveness of a gene panel compared to immunofluorescence mapping and transmission electron microscopy by analyzing its benefits, limitations, and economic aspects.
The gene panel included the 11 main genes associated with epidermolysis bullosa. The techniques were compared, assessing the average cost, advantages, and limitations, through a price survey and literature review.
Both immunofluorescence mapping and transmission electron microscopy require skin biopsy, are dependent on the investigator's expertise, and are subject to frequent inconclusive results. The gene panel is effective for the conclusive diagnosis of epidermolysis bullosa, presents high efficiency and accuracy, is economically feasible, and excludes the need for biopsy. The gene panel allows for prognosis, prenatal genetic diagnosis, and genetic counseling.
It was not possible to find laboratories that perform transmission electron microscopy for epidermolysis bullosa diagnosis in Brazil.
This study supports the gene panel as the first-choice method for epidermolysis bullosa diagnosis.
大疱性表皮松解症的特征是皮肤脆弱和水疱形成。历史上,通过免疫荧光定位或透射电子显微镜检查来实现诊断,这两种方法都需要进行活检。基因分析,尤其是通过下一代测序,是诊断这种疾病的重要工具。在巴西,诊断方法的可及性有限,因此大多数患者无法得到准确的诊断。诊断可以为患者提供预后指示和遗传咨询。
通过分析基因面板的获益、局限性和经济方面,评估其与免疫荧光定位和透射电子显微镜相比的成本效益。
基因面板包括与大疱性表皮松解症相关的 11 个主要基因。通过价格调查和文献回顾,比较了这些技术,评估了平均成本、优势和局限性。
免疫荧光定位和透射电子显微镜都需要皮肤活检,依赖于研究者的专业知识,并且经常出现不确定的结果。基因面板可有效明确诊断大疱性表皮松解症,具有高效和准确性,在经济上是可行的,并且可以避免活检。基因面板可用于预后、产前基因诊断和遗传咨询。
在巴西,无法找到进行大疱性表皮松解症诊断的透射电子显微镜实验室。
本研究支持基因面板作为大疱性表皮松解症诊断的首选方法。