University of British Columbia, School of Nursing, T201-2211 Wesbrook Mall, Vancouver, BC, V6T 2B5, Canada.
University of British Columbia, Centre for Health Services and Policy Research and School of Nursing, 2211 Wesbrook Mall, Vancouver, BC, V6T 2B5, Canada.
Int J Med Inform. 2021 May;149:104409. doi: 10.1016/j.ijmedinf.2021.104409. Epub 2021 Feb 10.
Frailty is considered an emerging syndrome characterized by a decrease in physiological ability to respond to stressors, leading to increased morbidity and mortality rates. Frailty is distinguished from normal age-associated decline because it is a sharp and often rapid decline rather than a gradual slowing down of general functioning. The comprehensive geriatric assessment is currently considered the gold standard for identifying frailty in older adults. The electronic version of this tool is called the eCGA and is commonly included in electronic medical records (EMR) in primary care settings.
We explored the adequacy of SNOMED CT to represent frailty concepts by addressing three research questions: 1) What are the defining characteristics of frailty most commonly used in frailty assessment tools? 2) Are these characteristics captured within one or many frailty assessment tools? 3) Which data elements from existing tool(s) can be reliably mapped to existing SNOMED CT terms?
We conducted a literature search to explore the defining characteristics of frailty and the most commonly used assessment tools. We compared these findings to the components of frailty captured within the eCGA. We then used a descriptive study design to manually map concepts from the eCGA to SNOMED CT.
Our literature review demonstrated that the eCGA contains all common defining characteristics of frailty. Unique assessment questions from the eCGA (n = 133) were manually mapped to SNOMED CT, using expert consensus. Of these, 72 % were direct matches, 17 % were one-to-many matches, and the remaining 11 % were non-matches. Two rounds of expert clinician mapping occurred; inter-rater reliability between the two clinicians was 0.75 (kappa).
CONCLUSIONS/IMPLICATIONS: The resulting list of mapped eCGA elements to SNOMED CT terms can inform revisions to existing chronic disease databases to include frailty monitoring and surveillance.
衰弱被认为是一种新兴综合征,其特征是生理应对压力源的能力下降,导致发病率和死亡率上升。衰弱与正常的年龄相关下降不同,因为它是一种急剧且通常迅速的下降,而不是一般功能的逐渐减缓。全面老年评估目前被认为是识别老年人衰弱的金标准。该工具的电子版称为电子全面老年评估,通常包含在初级保健环境中的电子病历 (EMR) 中。
我们通过回答三个研究问题来探讨 SNOMED CT 表示衰弱概念的充分性:1)在衰弱评估工具中最常用的衰弱的定义特征是什么?2)这些特征是否包含在一个或多个衰弱评估工具中?3)现有工具中的哪些数据元素可以可靠地映射到现有 SNOMED CT 术语?
我们进行了文献检索,以探讨衰弱的定义特征和最常用的评估工具。我们将这些发现与电子全面老年评估中包含的衰弱成分进行了比较。然后,我们使用描述性研究设计手动将电子全面老年评估的概念映射到 SNOMED CT。
我们的文献综述表明,电子全面老年评估包含所有常见的衰弱定义特征。电子全面老年评估中的独特评估问题(n=133)使用专家共识手动映射到 SNOMED CT。其中,72%是直接匹配,17%是一对多匹配,其余 11%是不匹配。进行了两轮专家临床医生映射;两名临床医生之间的组内相关系数为 0.75(kappa)。
结论/意义:映射到 SNOMED CT 术语的电子全面老年评估元素的列表可以为现有慢性病数据库的修订提供信息,以包括衰弱监测和监测。