School of Civil Engineering, Chongqing University, Chongqing, China.
Beijing Tsinghua Tongheng Urban Planning & Design Institute, Beijing, China.
PLoS One. 2021 Mar 10;16(3):e0248187. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0248187. eCollection 2021.
Eco-cities have witnessed rapid growth in these years worldwide. As the Eco-cities entering operation stage gradually, more and more researchers have found that users (who are living or working in the Eco-cities) satisfaction is one of the most important factors to determine the success or failure of Eco-cities. Therefore, it is very important to investigate the user demands to attract more citizens willing to live or work in the Eco-cities, which will make the development of Eco-cities more sustainable and solid. The recent researches on user demands investigation and analysis in the Eco-cities mainly focused on understanding the user need itself, yet lack of research on the relationship between the user demand and user satisfaction. This paper initially introduced the Kano model analysis method to the research field of user demands in Eco-city, to explore the relationship between the user demand and user satisfaction. After proposing user demands library in Eco-city (including Land use, Ecological environment, Green building, Energy utilization, etc.), the user demands classification and importance analysis methods of Eco-city were proposed based on Kano model. The questionnaire survey for users of two Eco-cities in China as case study was conducted, consisted of user demand items questionnaire based on the Kano model and a questionnaire on the importance of the user demand items. By utilizing the integration of quantitative analysis methods based on the Kano model and Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) method, the final ranking of user demands importance was obtained. Comparing with the existing literatures in terms of user demands research for Eco-city, the user demands analysis method based on Kano model of this paper, is able to reveal the influence degree of user satisfaction towards the facilities and services provided in the Eco-city. The user demands analysis method can be used for other researchers worldwide to investigate and quantitively analyze user demands according to their local development situation and preference of Eco-city. The user demands analysis results obtained through this method, can benefit different stages of Eco-city.
生态城市近年来在全球范围内得到了快速发展。随着生态城市逐渐进入运营阶段,越来越多的研究人员发现,用户(即在生态城市中生活或工作的人)满意度是决定生态城市成败的最重要因素之一。因此,调查用户需求对于吸引更多愿意在生态城市生活或工作的市民非常重要,这将使生态城市的发展更加可持续和稳固。近年来,生态城市用户需求调查和分析的研究主要集中在了解用户需求本身,而缺乏对用户需求与用户满意度之间关系的研究。本文将 Kano 模型分析方法引入生态城市用户需求研究领域,探讨用户需求与用户满意度之间的关系。在提出生态城市用户需求库(包括土地利用、生态环境、绿色建筑、能源利用等)后,基于 Kano 模型提出了生态城市用户需求分类和重要性分析方法。本研究以中国两个生态城市的用户为案例进行了问卷调查,问卷包括基于 Kano 模型的用户需求项目问卷和用户需求项目重要性问卷。通过利用基于 Kano 模型的定量分析方法和层次分析法(AHP)的综合集成,得出用户需求重要性的最终排名。与现有的生态城市用户需求研究文献相比,本文基于 Kano 模型的用户需求分析方法能够揭示用户满意度对生态城市提供的设施和服务的影响程度。该方法可用于其他研究人员根据当地发展情况和对生态城市的偏好,对用户需求进行调查和定量分析。通过该方法获得的用户需求分析结果可以使不同阶段的生态城市受益。