Department of Neurology, Section of Pediatric Neurology, Children's Wisconsin, Medical College of Wisconsin, USA. Correspondence to: Dr Hema Patel, Professor, Clinical Neurology, Department of Pediatric Neurology, 999, North 92nd Street, Suite 540, Milwaukee, WI 53226, USA.
Department of Clinical Psychiatry, Section of Child Psychology, Indiana University School of Medicine, USA.
Indian Pediatr. 2021 Mar 15;58(3):259-265.
Though psychogenic non-epileptic seizures (PNES) are seen commonly during evaluation of children and adolescents with epilepsy, the literature regarding developmental changes in PNES is limited.
Literature search was conducted in PubMed. Key search terms included: Pseudoseizure* OR PNES OR [(non-epileptic or nonepileptic or psychogenic or non-epileptic attack disorder) AND (seizure*)], resulting in 3,236 articles. Filters included human, ages 1-18 years, English language and last 15 years (2004-2019), resulting in 533 articles. We reviewed 33 articles, which included 19 articles that involved children (1-18 years), with 10 or more children with PNES in their study group. 21 articles obtained in cross references that were outside the filter setting (including time frame and age range) were also reviewed, for a total of 54 articles.
Majority of the studies were retrospective. We detail clinical features, predisposing factors and appropriate workup for children and adolescents with possible PNES. There is no consensus regarding frequency of psychiatric comorbidities in children with PNES. No controlled trials of treatment of PNES in children are available, but cognitive behavioral therapy is the consensus for adult PNES. Outcome appears to be better in children with PNES.
There is a need for be long-term prospective studies to document various clinical features and outcome of pediatric and adolescent PNES, and also the comorbid conditions.
虽然在评估癫痫儿童和青少年时经常会出现心因性非癫痫性发作(PNES),但关于 PNES 发育变化的文献有限。
在 PubMed 中进行了文献检索。关键搜索词包括:假性发作或 PNES 或[(非癫痫或非癫痫或心因性或非癫痫性发作障碍)和(发作)],共产生 3236 篇文章。筛选条件包括人类、年龄 1-18 岁、英语和过去 15 年(2004-2019 年),最终得到 533 篇文章。我们审查了 33 篇文章,其中包括 19 篇涉及儿童(1-18 岁)的文章,其研究组中有 10 名或更多患有 PNES 的儿童。还审查了交叉引用中超出筛选设置(包括时间范围和年龄范围)的 21 篇文章,总共 54 篇文章。
大多数研究都是回顾性的。我们详细介绍了儿童和青少年可能出现的 PNES 的临床特征、诱发因素和适当的检查。PNES 患儿的精神共病频率尚无共识。目前尚无针对儿童 PNES 的治疗的对照试验,但认知行为疗法是成人 PNES 的共识。PNES 患儿的预后似乎更好。
需要进行长期前瞻性研究,以记录儿科和青少年 PNES 的各种临床特征和结果,以及合并症。