Hunt Andrea McGraw, Fachner Jörg, Clark-Vetri Rachel, Raffa Robert B, Rupnow-Kidd Carrie, Maidhof Clemens, Dileo Cheryl
Department of Music, Rowan University, Glassboro, NJ, United States.
Cambridge Institute for Music Therapy Research, Anglia Ruskin University, Cambridge, United Kingdom.
Front Psychol. 2021 Feb 25;12:588788. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2021.588788. eCollection 2021.
Previous studies examining EEG and LORETA in patients with chronic pain discovered an overactivation of high theta (6-9 Hz) and low beta (12-16 Hz) power in central regions. MEG studies with healthy subjects correlating evoked nociception ratings and source localization described delta and gamma changes according to two music interventions. Using similar music conditions with chronic pain patients, we examined EEG in response to two different music interventions for pain. To study this process in-depth we conducted a mixed-methods case study approach, based on three clinical cases. Effectiveness of personalized music therapy improvisations (entrainment music - EM) versus preferred music on chronic pain was examined with 16 participants. Three patients were randomly selected for follow-up EEG sessions three months post-intervention, where they listened to recordings of the music from the interventions provided during the research. To test the difference of EM versus preferred music, recordings were presented in a block design: silence, their own composed EM (depicting both "pain" and "healing"), preferred (commercially available) music, and a non-participant's EM as a control. Participants rated their pain before and after the EEG on a 1-10 scale. We conducted a detailed single case analysis to compare all conditions, as well as a group comparison of entrainment-healing condition versus preferred music condition. Power spectrum and according LORETA distributions focused on expected changes in delta, theta, beta, and gamma frequencies, particularly in sensory-motor and central regions. Intentional moment-by-moment attention on the sounds/music rather than on pain and decreased awareness of pain was experienced from one participant. Corresponding EEG analysis showed accompanying power changes in sensory-motor regions and LORETA projection pointed to insula-related changes during entrainment-pain music. LORETA also indicated involvement of visual-spatial, motor, and language/music improvisation processing in response to his personalized EM which may reflect active recollection of creating the EM. Group-wide analysis showed common brain responses to personalized entrainment-healing music in theta and low beta range in right pre- and post-central gyrus. We observed somatosensory changes consistent with processing pain during entrainment-healing music that were not seen during preferred music. These results may depict top-down neural processes associated with active coping for pain.
先前针对慢性疼痛患者进行的脑电图(EEG)和低分辨率电磁断层扫描(LORETA)研究发现,中央区域的高θ波(6 - 9赫兹)和低β波(12 - 16赫兹)功率过度激活。对健康受试者进行的脑磁图(MEG)研究,将诱发的伤害感受评分与源定位相关联,描述了根据两种音乐干预产生的δ波和γ波变化。在慢性疼痛患者中采用类似的音乐条件,我们检测了EEG对两种不同疼痛音乐干预的反应。为了深入研究这一过程,我们基于三个临床病例采用了混合方法的案例研究方法。用16名参与者检验了个性化音乐疗法即兴创作(夹带音乐 - EM)与偏好音乐对慢性疼痛的有效性。随机选择三名患者在干预后三个月进行随访EEG检查,期间他们聆听研究期间提供的干预音乐录音。为了测试EM与偏好音乐的差异,录音以区组设计呈现:安静、他们自己创作的EM(描绘“疼痛”和“治愈”)、偏好的(市售)音乐,以及作为对照的非参与者的EM。参与者在EEG前后以1 - 10分的量表对疼痛进行评分。我们进行了详细的单病例分析以比较所有条件,以及夹带 - 治愈条件与偏好音乐条件的组间比较。功率谱以及相应的LORETA分布聚焦于δ波、θ波、β波和γ波频率的预期变化,特别是在感觉运动和中央区域。一名参与者体验到对声音/音乐的逐刻有意关注而非对疼痛的关注,以及疼痛意识的降低。相应的EEG分析显示感觉运动区域伴随功率变化,并且LORETA投影指向夹带 - 疼痛音乐期间与脑岛相关的变化。LORETA还表明视觉空间、运动以及语言/音乐即兴创作处理参与了对其个性化EM的反应,这可能反映了对创作EM的积极回忆。全组分析显示,右侧中央前回和中央后回在θ波和低β波范围内对个性化夹带 - 治愈音乐有共同的脑反应。我们观察到在夹带 - 治愈音乐期间与疼痛处理一致的体感变化,而在偏好音乐期间未观察到。这些结果可能描绘了与积极应对疼痛相关的自上而下的神经过程。