Schwarz Julia, Vidondo Beatriz, Maninchedda Ugo E, Sprick Miriam, Schöpfer Melina C, Cruz Antonio M
Vetsuisse Faculty, Institut Suisse de Medicine Equine, University of Bern, Bern, Switzerland.
Vetsuisse Faculty, Veterinary Public Health Institute, University of Bern, Bern, Switzerland.
Front Vet Sci. 2021 Mar 4;8:595455. doi: 10.3389/fvets.2021.595455. eCollection 2021.
To assess the inter-evaluator and intra-evaluator reliability of a software program used to extract kinematic variables by a commercially available extremity-mounted inertial measurement unit system in sound horses at the trot under soft and hard ground conditions and treadmill exercise. Thirty adult, sound and healthy French Montagne stallions. Data collection was performed with six IMUs strapped to the distal, metacarpal, metatarsal and tibial regions of every horse. Per surface (treadmill, soft and hard ground) 10 stallions were trotted three times. Prior to the analysis done by six evaluators (three experienced, three inexperienced) the data was blinded and copied three times. For every analysis a minimum of five strides had to be selected. To assess the intra- and inter-evaluator reliability a selection of gait variables was used to calculate intra and inter correlation coefficients (ICCs) as well as variance partitioning coefficients (VPCs). All of the tested gait variables showed high levels of reliability. There was no mentionable difference considering the correlation coefficients between the intra and inter reliability as well as between the three different surfaces. VPCs showed that the factor horse is by far the most responsible for any appearing variance. The experience of the evaluator had no influence on the results. The software program tested in this study has a high inter- and intra-evaluator reliability under the chosen conditions for the selected variables and acts independent of the ground situation and the experience of the evaluator. On the condition of a correct application it has the potential to become a clinically relevant and reliable gait analysis tool.
评估一种软件程序的评估者间和评估者内可靠性,该软件程序用于通过市售的肢体安装惯性测量单元系统,在软质和硬质地面条件以及跑步机运动下,提取健康马匹小跑时的运动学变量。选取30匹成年、健康的法国蒙塔涅种公马。在每匹马的远端、掌骨、跖骨和胫骨区域捆绑六个惯性测量单元(IMU)进行数据采集。在每个平面(跑步机、软质地面和硬质地面)上,10匹种公马小跑三次。在由六名评估者(三名经验丰富的,三名经验不足的)进行分析之前,数据进行了盲法处理并复制了三份。每次分析必须至少选择五步。为了评估评估者内和评估者间的可靠性,选取了一系列步态变量来计算组内和组间相关系数(ICC)以及方差分配系数(VPC)。所有测试的步态变量都显示出高度的可靠性。考虑组内和组间可靠性之间以及三个不同平面之间的相关系数,没有明显差异。VPC表明,马匹因素是出现任何方差的最主要原因。评估者的经验对结果没有影响。在本研究中测试的软件程序在所选择的条件下,对于所选变量具有较高的评估者间和评估者内可靠性,并且其作用与地面情况和评估者的经验无关。在正确应用的情况下,它有可能成为一种临床相关且可靠的步态分析工具。