Tee James, Taylor Desmond P
Department of Psychology, New York University. He is now with the Communications Research Group, Department of Electrical & Computer Engineering, University of Canterbury, Private Bag 4800, Christchurch 8020, New Zealand.
Communications Research Group, Department of Electrical & Computer Engineering, University of Canterbury, Private Bag 4800, Christchurch 8020, New Zealand.
IEEE Trans Mol Biol Multiscale Commun. 2019 Oct;5(1):19-29. doi: 10.1109/tmbmc.2019.2950182. Epub 2019 Oct 30.
Conventional and current wisdom assumes that the brain represents probability as a continuous number to many decimal places. This assumption seems implausible given finite and scarce resources in the brain. Quantization is an information encoding process whereby a continuous quantity is systematically divided into a finite number of possible categories. Rounding is a simple example of quantization. We apply this information theoretic concept to develop a novel quantized (i.e., discrete) probability distortion function. We develop three conjunction probability gambling tasks to look for evidence of quantized probability representations in the brain. We hypothesize that certain ranges of probability will be lumped together in the same indifferent category if a quantized representation exists. For example, two distinct probabilities such as 0.57 and 0.585 may be treated indifferently. Our extensive data analysis has found strong evidence to support such a quantized representation: 59/76 participants (i.e., 78%) demonstrated a best fit to 4-bit quantized models instead of continuous models. This observation is the major development and novelty of the present work. The brain is very likely to be employing a quantized representation of probability. This discovery demonstrates a major precision limitation of the brain's representational and decision-making ability.
传统观点及当下的普遍看法认为,大脑将概率表示为一个具有许多小数位的连续数字。鉴于大脑中资源有限且稀缺,这一假设似乎难以置信。量化是一种信息编码过程,通过该过程,一个连续量被系统地划分为有限数量的可能类别。四舍五入就是量化的一个简单例子。我们应用这一信息论概念来开发一种新颖的量化(即离散)概率失真函数。我们设计了三个联合概率赌博任务,以寻找大脑中量化概率表示的证据。我们假设,如果存在量化表示,那么某些概率范围将被归为同一无差异类别。例如,两个不同的概率,如0.57和0.585,可能会被无差异对待。我们广泛的数据分析发现了有力证据支持这种量化表示:76名参与者中有59名(即78%)表现出最符合4位量化模型而非连续模型。这一观察结果是本研究的主要进展和新颖之处。大脑很可能采用概率的量化表示。这一发现表明了大脑表征和决策能力的一个主要精度限制。