Tee James, Taylor Desmond P
Department of Psychology, New York University.
Communications Research Group, Department of Electrical & Computer Engineering, University of Canterbury, Private Bag 4800, Christchurch 8020, New Zealand.
IEEE Trans Mol Biol Multiscale Commun. 2021 Mar;7(1):1-9. doi: 10.1109/TMBMC.2020.3025244. Epub 2020 Sep 21.
Value [4][5] is typically modeled using a continuous representation (i.e., a Real number). A discrete representation of value has recently been postulated [6]. A quantized representation of probability in the brain was also posited and supported by experimental data [7]. Value and probability are inter-related via Prospect Theory [4][5]. In this paper, we hypothesize that intertemporal choices may also be quantized. For example, people may treat (or discount) 16 days indifferently to 17 days. To test this, we analyzed an intertemporal task by using 2 novel models: quantized hyperbolic discounting, and quantized exponential discounting. Our work here is a re-examination of the behavioral data previously collected for an fMRI study [8]. Both quantized hyperbolic and quantized exponential models were compared using AIC and BIC tests. We found that 13/20 participants were best fit to the quantized exponential model, while the remaining 7/20 were best fit to the quantized hyperbolic model. Overall, 15/20 participants were best fit to models with a 5-bit precision (i.e., 2 = 32 steps). In conclusion, regardless of hyperbolic or exponential, quantized versions of these models are better fit to the experimental data than their continuous forms. We finally outline some potential applications of our findings.
值[4][5]通常使用连续表示(即实数)来建模。最近有人提出了值的离散表示[6]。大脑中概率的量化表示也已被提出,并得到了实验数据的支持[7]。值和概率通过前景理论相互关联[4][5]。在本文中,我们假设跨期选择也可能是量化的。例如,人们可能对16天和17天无差异对待(或贴现)。为了验证这一点,我们使用两种新模型分析了一个跨期任务:量化双曲线贴现和量化指数贴现。我们这里的工作是对之前为一项功能磁共振成像研究收集的行为数据的重新审视[8]。使用AIC和BIC检验对量化双曲线模型和量化指数模型进行了比较。我们发现,20名参与者中有13名最适合量化指数模型,而其余7名最适合量化双曲线模型。总体而言,20名参与者中有15名最适合精度为5位(即2 = 32步)的模型。总之,无论双曲线还是指数模型,这些模型的量化版本都比其连续形式更适合实验数据。我们最后概述了我们研究结果的一些潜在应用。