Klinikum der Universität München, Medizinische Klinik und Poliklinik IV, Munich, Germany.
LMU München, Klinikum der Universität München, Institut für Didaktik und Ausbildungsforschung in der Medizin, Munich, Germany.
GMS J Med Educ. 2021 Feb 15;38(2):Doc43. doi: 10.3205/zma001439. eCollection 2021.
The main aim of medical curricula is to prepare students for the first day at the work place. While teaching clinical competence is pivotal, clinical clerkships are often the last chance to close knowledge gaps with the help of clinical teachers. Self-directed learning is a dynamic field for research within medical education, though its curricular implementation is rare. This study focuses on the needs assessment of clinical clerkships using the concept of self-directed learning. The study comprised an educational experience at the Ludwig-Maximilians Universität (LMU) Munich. Medical students (n=1446, 59% female) in their second clinical year were instructed to specify learning objectives (LOs) by Doran`s SMART criteria and to gauge the probability of their fulfilment prior to the mandatory clerkship. In a second questionnaire one week later, the students rated the actual subjective fulfilment of the LOs. Data was coded with regards to the German National Catalogue of Competence-Based Learning Objectives for Undergraduate Medical Education (NKLM) and investigated qualitatively. Factors that determine goal achievement were collected and coded binary (barrier vs. enabler). Univariate analysis was used when appropriate. The acquisition of "clinically practical abilities" (29%), "diagnostic methods" (21%) and "professional communication" (13%) were the LOs mentioned most. Throughout the week, subjective fulfilment diminished. Rich (vs. poor) availability to "practical exercise" (31%), "engagement of the physicians and other medical staff" (27%) and "personal initiative" (23%) resulted in higher subjective fulfilment. The self-chosen LOs reflect the needs of students for which the clinical teacher should be prepared. Considering these findings, it seems possible to close practical training gaps. We support the consideration of establishing curricular anchored self-directed learning in clinical clerkships. Further empirical studies would be beneficial in revealing its positive effects on the learning progress.
医学课程的主要目标是让学生为第一天工作做好准备。虽然教授临床能力至关重要,但临床实习通常是在临床教师的帮助下弥补知识差距的最后机会。自主学习是医学教育中一个研究活跃的领域,尽管其课程实施很少。本研究使用自主学习的概念来关注临床实习的需求评估。
该研究包括在慕尼黑路德维希-马克西米利安大学(LMU)的一次教育经历。第二年临床学习的医学生(n=1446,女性占 59%)被指示根据 Doran 的 SMART 标准指定学习目标(LOs),并在必修实习前评估其实现的可能性。一周后,学生们在第二份问卷中评估了 LOs 的实际主观实现情况。数据根据德国国家基于能力的本科医学教育学习目标目录(NKLM)进行了编码,并进行了定性研究。收集并编码了决定目标实现的因素(障碍与促进因素)。适当的时候使用了单变量分析。
学生提到最多的学习目标是“临床实践能力”(29%)、“诊断方法”(21%)和“专业沟通”(13%)。整个星期,主观满意度都在下降。丰富(而非贫乏)的“实践练习”(31%)、“医生和其他医务人员的参与”(27%)和“个人主动性”(23%)的获得导致了更高的主观满意度。
学生自主选择的学习目标反映了他们对临床教师的需求。考虑到这些发现,似乎有可能弥补实践培训差距。我们支持考虑在临床实习中建立课程挂钩的自主学习。进一步的实证研究将有助于揭示其对学习进展的积极影响。