CREA Research Center for Cereal and Industrial Crops, Bologna, Italy.
Faculty of Agricultural Sciences and Technologies, Sivas University of Science and Technology, Sivas, Turkey.
PLoS One. 2021 Mar 25;16(3):e0249136. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0249136. eCollection 2021.
Crop yield monitoring demonstrated the potential to improve agricultural productivity through improved crop breeding, farm management and commodity planning. Remote and proximal sensing offer the possibility to cut crop monitoring costs traditionally associated with surveys and censuses. Fraction of absorbed photosynthetically active radiation (fAPAR), chlorophyll concentration (CI) and normalized difference vegetation (NDVI) indices were used in crop monitoring, but their comparative performances in sorghum monitoring is lacking. This work aimed therefore at closing this gap by evaluating the performance of machine learning modelling of in-season sorghum biomass yields based on Sentinel-2-derived fAPAR and simpler high-throughput optical handheld meters-derived NDVI and CI calculated from sorghum plants reflectance. Bayesian ridge regression showed good cross-validated performance, and high reliability (R2 = 35%) and low bias (mean absolute prediction error, MAPE = 0.4%) during the validation step. Hand-held optical meter-derived CI and Sentinel-2-derived fAPAR showed comparable effects on machine learning performance, but CI outperformed NDVI and was therefore considered as a good alternative to Sentinel-2's fAPAR. The best times to sample the vegetation indices were the months of June (second half) and July. The results obtained in this work will serve several purposes including improvements in plant breeding, farming management and sorghum biomass yield forecasting at extension services and policy making levels.
作物产量监测有望通过改良作物品种、农场管理和商品规划来提高农业生产力。远程和近程感应为降低传统作物监测成本(与调查和普查相关的成本)提供了可能。吸收的光合有效辐射(fAPAR)、叶绿素浓度(CI)和归一化植被差异(NDVI)指数被用于作物监测,但它们在高粱监测中的比较性能尚不清楚。因此,这项工作旨在通过评估基于 Sentinel-2 衍生的 fAPAR 以及从高粱植株反射率计算的更简单的高通量光学手持式仪表衍生的 NDVI 和 CI 的机器学习模型在高粱生物量产量的季节性监测中的表现来填补这一空白。贝叶斯脊回归显示出良好的交叉验证性能,在验证步骤中具有高可靠性(R2=35%)和低偏差(平均绝对预测误差,MAPE=0.4%)。手持式光学仪表衍生的 CI 和 Sentinel-2 衍生的 fAPAR 对机器学习性能的影响相当,但 CI 优于 NDVI,因此被认为是 Sentinel-2 的 fAPAR 的良好替代品。采集植被指数的最佳时间是 6 月(下半年)和 7 月。这项工作的结果将有几个用途,包括在植物育种、农业管理和高粱生物量产量预测方面的改进,以及在推广服务和决策制定层面上。