Owoyemi Olutosin, Aakhus Erin
Perelman School of Medicine, The University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA.
Oncologist. 2021 Aug;26(8):630-634. doi: 10.1002/onco.13771. Epub 2021 Apr 19.
Underrepresentation of minority groups in the oncology physician workforce is a pressing issue that may contribute to disparities in cancer research, clinical care, and patient outcomes. To address this, we highlight the role of medical culture and institutions in perpetuating a range of barriers that lead to the persistent underrepresentation of minority medical trainees and physicians. These barriers include an exclusionary medical culture, bias in measures of merit, financial barriers to medical subspecialty training, underrecognition of achievement, and poor representation and satisfaction among underrepresented faculty. Furthermore, we suggest a more intentional approach to diversity that values both recruitment of underrepresented undergraduates and early medical students and retention of internal medicine trainees, hematology-oncology fellows, and faculty. To counteract deeply embedded structural racism that hampers diversity efforts, this multifaceted approach will require cultural transformation of our medical institutions at all levels, including increased institutional transparency, mandatory evidence-based bias training, acknowledgment of varied achievements, changes in recruitment practices, and reinvigoration of pipeline development programs with a focus on financial support. Taken in combination, programs should recognize the scope of deterrents to representation and develop program-specific, longitudinal interventions to promote more successful diversity initiatives within the field of oncology. IMPLICATIONS FOR PRACTICE: The medical profession recognizes the value of physician workforce diversity in improving the quality of both medical education and patient care. In return, medical schools and training programs invest in recruitment programs focused on candidates who are underrepresented in medicine. In the field of oncology, where stark racial and ethnic disparities in care and health outcomes are well-defined, measures of minority physician representation remain especially stagnant. This study clearly defines the barriers that limit the effectiveness of such programs and provides recommendations to achieve the necessary workforce diversity in oncology.
少数群体在肿瘤学医生队伍中的代表性不足是一个紧迫的问题,可能导致癌症研究、临床护理和患者治疗结果方面的差异。为了解决这一问题,我们强调了医学文化和机构在延续一系列障碍方面所起的作用,这些障碍导致少数族裔医学实习生和医生持续代表性不足。这些障碍包括排他性的医学文化、绩效衡量中的偏见、医学亚专业培训的经济障碍、对成就的认识不足以及代表性不足的教职员工中代表性差和满意度低。此外,我们建议采取一种更具针对性的多元化方法,既要重视招收代表性不足的本科生和早期医学生,也要重视留住内科实习生、血液肿瘤学研究员和教职员工。为了消除阻碍多元化努力的根深蒂固的结构性种族主义,这种多方面的方法将需要对我们各级医疗机构进行文化变革,包括提高机构透明度、强制性的基于证据的偏见培训、承认不同的成就、改变招聘做法以及重振以财政支持为重点的人才培养计划。综合起来,各项计划应认识到代表性方面的阻碍范围,并制定针对具体计划的纵向干预措施,以促进肿瘤学领域更成功的多元化举措。对实践的启示:医学界认识到医生队伍多元化在提高医学教育质量和患者护理质量方面的价值。作为回报,医学院校和培训项目投资于针对医学领域代表性不足的候选人的招聘项目。在肿瘤学领域,护理和健康结果方面明显的种族和族裔差异已得到明确界定,但少数族裔医生的代表性衡量指标仍然特别停滞不前。这项研究明确界定了限制此类项目有效性的障碍,并提供了实现肿瘤学领域必要的劳动力多元化的建议。