Faculty of Education and Social Work, University of Vigo, 32004 Ourense, Spain.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2021 Mar 4;18(5):2555. doi: 10.3390/ijerph18052555.
Adolescence, a period of physical, social, cognitive and emotional development, represents a target population for sexual health promotion and education when it comes to achieving the 2030 Agenda goals for sustainable and equitable societies. The aim of this study is to provide an overview of what is known about the dissemination and effectiveness of sex education programs and thereby to inform better public policy making in this area. : We carried out a systematic review based on international scientific literature, in which only peer-reviewed papers were included. To identify reviews, we carried out an electronic search of the Cochrane Database Reviews, ERIC, Web of Science, PubMed, Medline, Scopus and PsycINFO. This paper provides a narrative review of reviews of the literature from 2015 to 2020. : 20 reviews met the inclusion criteria (10 in school settings, 9 using digital platforms and 1 blended learning program): they focused mainly on reducing risk behaviors (e.g., VIH/STIs and unwanted pregnancies), whilst obviating themes such as desire and pleasure, which were not included in outcome evaluations. The reviews with the lowest risk of bias are those carried out in school settings and are the ones that most question the effectiveness of sex education programs. Whilst the reviews of digital platforms and blended learning show greater effectiveness in terms of promoting sexual and reproductive health in adolescents (ASRH), they nevertheless also include greater risks of bias. : A more rigorous assessment of the effectiveness of sexual education programs is necessary, especially regarding the opportunities offered by new technologies, which may lead to more cost-effective interventions than with in-person programs. Moreover, blended learning programs offer a promising way forward, as they combine the best of face-to-face and digital interventions, and may provide an excellent tool in the new context of the COVID-19 pandemic.
青春期是身体、社会、认知和情感发展的时期,当涉及到实现可持续和公平社会的 2030 年议程目标时,它代表了促进和教育性健康的目标人群。本研究旨在概述性教育计划的传播和效果,从而为该领域的更好的公共政策制定提供信息。
我们进行了一项基于国际科学文献的系统综述,其中仅包括同行评议的论文。为了识别综述,我们对 Cochrane 数据库综述、ERIC、Web of Science、PubMed、Medline、Scopus 和 PsycINFO 进行了电子搜索。本文提供了对 2015 年至 2020 年文献综述的叙述性综述。
有 20 篇综述符合纳入标准(10 篇在学校环境中进行,9 篇使用数字平台,1 篇混合学习计划):它们主要集中在减少风险行为(例如,艾滋病毒/性传播感染和意外怀孕),同时避免了欲望和愉悦等主题,这些主题未包含在结果评估中。在学校环境中进行的、具有最低偏倚风险的综述对性教育计划的有效性提出了最多的质疑。虽然数字平台和混合学习的综述在促进青少年的性和生殖健康(ASRH)方面显示出更高的效果,但它们也包括更高的偏倚风险。
需要更严格地评估性教育计划的有效性,特别是关于新技术提供的机会,这可能导致比面对面计划更具成本效益的干预措施。此外,混合学习计划提供了一个有前途的前进方向,因为它们结合了面对面和数字干预的最佳效果,并且可能是在 COVID-19 大流行的新背景下提供的极好工具。