School of Agricultural Economics and Rural Development, Renmin University of China, Beijing 100872, China.
Global Data Insight and Analytics, Ford Motor Company, Dearborn, MI 48126, USA.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2021 Mar 19;18(6):3178. doi: 10.3390/ijerph18063178.
The Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) is designed to improve household diet and food security-a pressing problem confronting low-income families in the United States. Previous studies on the issue often ignored the methodological issue of endogenous program participation. We revisit this important issue by estimating a simultaneous equation system with ordinal household food insecurity. Data are drawn from the 2009-2011 Current Population Survey Food Security Supplement (CPS-FSS), restricted to SNAP-eligible households with children. Our results add to the stocks of empirical findings that SNAP participation ameliorates food insecurity among adults only, but increases the probabilities of low and very low food security among children. These contradictory results indicate that our selection approach with a single cross section is only partially successful, and that additional efforts are needed in further analyses of this complicated issue, perhaps with longitudinal data. Socio-demographic variables are found to affect food-secure households and food-insecure households differently, but affect SNAP nonparticipants and participants in the same direction. The state policy tools, such as broad-based categorical eligibility (BBCE) and simplified reporting, can encourage SNAP participation and thus ameliorate food insecurity. Our findings can inform policy deliberations.
补充营养援助计划(SNAP)旨在改善家庭饮食和粮食安全,这是美国低收入家庭面临的紧迫问题。以往关于这个问题的研究往往忽略了计划参与的内生性这一方法学问题。我们通过估计一个带有有序家庭粮食不安全的联立方程组来重新审视这个重要问题。数据来自 2009-2011 年的当前人口调查粮食安全补充调查(CPS-FSS),仅限于有孩子的符合 SNAP 条件的家庭。我们的结果增加了实证研究的发现,即 SNAP 参与只改善了成年人的粮食不安全状况,但增加了儿童粮食不安全的低和极低的可能性。这些矛盾的结果表明,我们的单截面选择方法只是部分成功,需要在进一步分析这个复杂问题时,可能需要使用纵向数据,进行额外的努力。社会人口变量被发现对粮食安全家庭和粮食不安全家庭有不同的影响,但对 SNAP 非参与者和参与者的影响是相同的。州政策工具,如广泛的类别资格(BBCE)和简化报告,可以鼓励 SNAP 参与,从而改善粮食不安全状况。我们的研究结果可以为政策审议提供信息。