Keskin Merve, Ooms Kristien, Dogru Ahmet Ozgur, De Maeyer Philippe
Ghent University, Ghent, Belgium.
Istanbul Technical University, Istanbul, Turkey.
J Eye Mov Res. 2018 Jun 15;11(3). doi: 10.16910/jemr.11.3.4.
This paper explores map users' cognitive processes in learning, acquiring and remembering information presented via screen maps. In this context, we conducted a mixed-methods user experiment employing digital sketch maps and eye tracking. On the one hand, the performance of the participants was assessed based on the order with which the objects were drawn and the influence of visual variables (e.g. presence & location, size, shape, color). On the other hand, trial durations and eye tracking statistics such as average duration of fixations, and number of fixations per seconds were compared. Moreover, selected AoIs (Area of Interests) were explored to gain a deeper insight on visual behavior of map users. Depending on the normality of the data, we used either two-way ANOVA or Mann-Whitney U test to inspect the significance of the results. Based on the evaluation of the drawing order, we observed that experts and males drew roads first whereas; novices and females focused more on hydrographic object. According to the assessment of drawn elements, no significant differences emerged between neither experts and novices, nor females and males for the retrieval of spatial information presented on 2D maps with a simple design and content. The differences in trial durations between novices and experts were not statistically significant while both studying and drawing. Similarly, no significant difference occurred between female and male participants for either studying or drawing. Eye tracking metrics also supported these findings. For average duration of fixation, there was found no significant difference between experts and novices, as well as between females and males. Similarly, no significant differences were found for the mean number of fixation.
本文探讨了地图用户在学习、获取和记忆通过屏幕地图呈现的信息时的认知过程。在此背景下,我们进行了一项混合方法的用户实验,采用数字草图地图和眼动追踪技术。一方面,根据参与者绘制对象的顺序以及视觉变量(如存在与位置、大小、形状、颜色)的影响来评估他们的表现。另一方面,比较了试验持续时间和眼动追踪统计数据,如平均注视持续时间和每秒注视次数。此外,还对选定的感兴趣区域进行了探索,以更深入地了解地图用户的视觉行为。根据数据的正态性,我们使用双向方差分析或曼-惠特尼U检验来检验结果的显著性。基于对绘制顺序的评估,我们观察到专家和男性首先绘制道路,而新手和女性则更关注水文地理对象。根据对绘制元素的评估,在具有简单设计和内容的二维地图上呈现的空间信息检索方面,专家与新手之间以及女性与男性之间均未出现显著差异。新手和专家在学习和绘制过程中的试验持续时间差异在统计学上不显著。同样,女性和男性参与者在学习或绘制方面也没有显著差异。眼动追踪指标也支持了这些发现。在平均注视持续时间方面,专家与新手之间以及女性与男性之间均未发现显著差异。同样,在平均注视次数方面也未发现显著差异。