Carrillo Katty Coral, Drouet Juan Cabrera, Rodríguez-Romero Araceli, Tovar-Sánchez Antonio, Ruiz-Gutiérrez Gema, Viguri Fuente Javier R
Facultad de Ingeniería y Ciencias Aplicadas, Universidad Internacional SEK, C) Alberto Einstein y 5a Transversal, Quito, Ecuador.
Facultad de Ingeniería y Ciencias Aplicadas, Universidad Internacional SEK, C) Alberto Einstein y 5a Transversal, Quito, Ecuador.
J Environ Manage. 2021 Jul 1;289:112495. doi: 10.1016/j.jenvman.2021.112495. Epub 2021 Apr 5.
This study quantifies the degree of pollution and assess the ecological risk of As, Ba, Cd, Co, Cr, Cu, Mo, Ni, Pb, V and Zn in sediments and soils of the Limoncocha Biological Reserve (Ecuador), identified as a Ramsar site with high ecological and socioeconomic value. The hydrologic system of the Reserve is mainly formed by two rivers that drain into the Limoncocha lagoon, which occupies only five percent of the protected area but support a high anthropic influence. Local statistical baseline of studied potentially toxic elements is established using cumulative frequency method, and Al is selected as reference element due to the good correlation with the studied elements. The grade of pollution and the potential ecological risk are evaluated applying three individual (Contamination Factor, Geo-accumulation Index and Enrichment Factor) and six integrated (Degree and modified degree of contamination, Pollution Load Index, Nemerow and modified Nemerow pollution indexes and potential ecological risk index) indices. Results analysis are based on the combined application of traditional statistics, multivariate data analysis and self organizing maps. Outcomes suggest to classify sediments and soils as "moderate contamination and enrichment" due mainly to the concentrations of Cu (66.4-110 mg/kg) and Cd (0.0262-0.808 mg/kg), derived from domestic wastewaters and agricultural activities, and in a lesser extent due to Mo (0.822-4.37 mg/kg), Ni (10.3-25.8 mg/kg), Co (7.27-24.8 mg/kg) and V (60.3-178 mg/kg), derived from oil field drilling activities. The distributions of As (0.328-8.83 mg/kg), Ba (143-1100 mg/kg), Pb (7.20-26.5 mg/kg), Zn (60.1-276 mg/kg) and Cr (10.1-48.6 mg/kg) are heterogeneous in the studied sampling sites. Sediments located next to the pier and at the central area of the Limoncocha lagoon, show moderate potential risk and according to sediment quality guidelines, the calculated mean Effect Range Median quotient (mERMq) classify the sites as medium-low priority risk level. A three-level classification of a mean quotient based on soil quality and soil potential uses is proposed. Soil sites with high anthropogenic activities show low to moderate potential ecological risk being classified as poor soil quality sites but with all potential soil uses allowed according to the legal limits for land uses in Ecuador.
本研究对被认定为具有高生态和社会经济价值的拉姆萨尔湿地——厄瓜多的利蒙科查生物保护区沉积物和土壤中砷、钡、镉、钴、铬、铜、钼、镍、铅、钒和锌的污染程度进行了量化,并评估了其生态风险。该保护区的水文系统主要由两条流入利蒙科查泻湖的河流构成,该泻湖仅占保护区面积的5%,却受到高度的人类活动影响。利用累积频率法建立了所研究的潜在有毒元素的当地统计基线,并选择铝作为参考元素,因为它与所研究元素具有良好的相关性。应用三个单独的指数(污染因子、地累积指数和富集因子)和六个综合指数(污染程度和修正污染程度、污染负荷指数、内梅罗和修正内梅罗污染指数以及潜在生态风险指数)来评估污染等级和潜在生态风险。结果分析基于传统统计、多元数据分析和自组织映射的联合应用。结果表明,沉积物和土壤主要因来自生活污水和农业活动的铜(66.4 - 110毫克/千克)和镉(0.0262 - 0.808毫克/千克)浓度,在较小程度上因来自油田钻探活动的钼(0.822 - 4.37毫克/千克)、镍(10.3 - 25.8毫克/千克)、钴(7.27 - 24.8毫克/千克)和钒(60.3 - 178毫克/千克)浓度,而被归类为“中度污染和富集”。在所研究的采样点中,砷(0.328 - 8.83毫克/千克)、钡(143 - 1100毫克/千克)、铅(7.20 - 26.5毫克/千克)、锌(60.1 - 276毫克/千克)和铬(10.1 - 48.6毫克/千克)的分布是不均匀的。码头附近和利蒙科查泻湖中心区域的沉积物显示出中度潜在风险,根据沉积物质量指南,计算得出的平均效应范围中位数商(mERMq)将这些地点归类为中低优先级风险水平。提出了基于土壤质量和土壤潜在用途的平均商数三级分类法。人类活动高度活跃的土壤地点显示出低至中度的潜在生态风险,被归类为土壤质量较差的地点,但根据厄瓜多尔土地使用的法定限制,所有潜在的土壤用途都是允许的。