Hubel Grace S, Cooley John L, Moreland Angela D
Department of Psychology, The College of Charleston, Charleston, South Carolina.
Department of Psychiatry, Developmental Psychobiology Research Group, University of Colorado Anschutz Medical Campus, Aurora, Colorado.
Psychol Sch. 2020 May;57(5):735-756. doi: 10.1002/pits.22348. Epub 2020 Feb 5.
Development of a multicomponent mental health consultation program for a countywide Head Start program is described. The consultation program incorporates strategies from the evidence-based practice, Teacher-Child Interaction Training (TCIT). Through large group professional development trainings before the school year, comprehensive feedback reports based on observations, and in-class coaching via modeling and performance feedback on teachers' use of TCIT skills, the consultation program served 55 Head Start classrooms with 789 children. Outcome data are presented on teachers' improvement in TCIT skill use and the relative effectiveness of two coaching methods (i.e., modeling and performance feedback) used during consultation. Results from multilevel modeling analyses indicated that teachers improved in the use of multiple observed TCIT skills between the initial and midyear assessment (i.e., increased frequency of labeled praises, reflections, behavioral descriptions, and commands that were complied with; decreased frequency of commands that children did not have an opportunity to comply with). Additionally, teachers who received coaching in the form of performance feedback, in comparison to modeling, exhibited greater gains in the frequency of labeled praises and commands that resulted in compliance. Discussion focuses on implementation of evidence-based practice in large-scale preventative early interventions, study limitations, and directions for future research.
本文描述了为一个全县范围内的“启智计划”项目开发的多成分心理健康咨询项目。该咨询项目纳入了基于证据的实践——师生互动训练(TCIT)的策略。通过在学年开始前进行的大型专业发展培训、基于观察的综合反馈报告,以及通过对教师使用TCIT技能的示范和表现反馈进行课堂指导,该咨询项目服务了55个“启智计划”教室的789名儿童。呈现了关于教师在使用TCIT技能方面的改进以及咨询期间使用的两种指导方法(即示范和表现反馈)的相对有效性的结果数据。多层次建模分析的结果表明,在初始评估和年中评估之间,教师在使用多种观察到的TCIT技能方面有所改进(即标记表扬、反思、行为描述和得到遵守的指令的频率增加;儿童没有机会遵守的指令的频率降低)。此外,与示范相比,接受表现反馈形式指导的教师在标记表扬和导致遵守的指令的频率方面有更大的提高。讨论集中在大规模预防性早期干预中基于证据的实践的实施、研究局限性以及未来研究的方向。