Abdelaziz Adel, Mansour Tayseer, Alkhadragy Rania, Abdel Nasser Asmaa, Hasnain Memoona
Medical Education Department, Faculty of Medicine, Suez Canal University, Ismailia, Egypt.
Medical Education Unit, Ibn Sina National College, Jeddah, Saudi Arabia.
Adv Med Educ Pract. 2021 Apr 1;12:329-336. doi: 10.2147/AMEP.S273033. eCollection 2021.
In Egypt, the main challenges to interprofessional education (IPE) implementation are complexity of the required curricular design, the attitudinal barriers between professions, and the needed resources. Action research work was planned and implemented to identify alternative solutions to overcome barriers to IPE in the local Egyptian context.
-An 8-week e-learning elective course was developed, implemented, and evaluated. A mixed group of 30 nursing and medical students was enrolled voluntarily in the course. Female to male ratio was 3:2. Four faculty members were assigned to manage the course. Based on the EMRO-WHO guidelines, ethics content was selected and organized. A closed Facebook group was created and utilized as the e-learning platform. Facilitated large-group and case-based discussions were the main instructional methods. Scoring of mixed small group assignments was the main assessment tool. Course evaluation was conducted using the Interprofessional Socialization and Valuing Scale (ISVS) and an Online-Course Evaluation Questionnaire (OCEQ).
ISVS results revealed that students' perception of ability, comfort and value in working with others, were all positive. The OCEQ provided additional evidence regarding the satisfaction of students with the Facebook group as a learning platform. Assignment submission rate was 90%. Success rate of small group assignments (scores ≥ 60%) was 100%. Response rate to the open online discussions was 63%. Through peer evaluation as well as direct observation of online discussions, there was evidence of distinct contributions by females and by medical students compared to nursing students.
As evidenced by the students' perception and performance, our IPE distance learning experience was valuable. Motivation of medical students as well as females was evident. IPE is a challenging process. The elective approach and using DL can offer solutions. Conducting relevant practical sessions as well as sustainability of this IPE e-learning experience remain key challenges.
在埃及,跨专业教育(IPE)实施面临的主要挑战包括所需课程设计的复杂性、专业间的态度障碍以及所需资源。计划并开展了行动研究工作,以确定在埃及当地背景下克服IPE障碍的替代解决方案。
开发、实施并评估了一门为期8周的电子学习选修课程。30名护理和医学专业学生自愿报名参加该课程,男女比例为3:2。指定了四名教员管理该课程。根据东地中海区域办事处-世界卫生组织指南选择并组织了伦理内容。创建了一个封闭的脸书群组并将其用作电子学习平台。以促进大组讨论和基于案例的讨论为主要教学方法。混合小组作业评分是主要评估工具。使用跨专业社会化和重视量表(ISVS)和在线课程评价问卷(OCEQ)进行课程评价。
ISVS结果显示,学生对与他人合作的能力、舒适度和价值的看法均为积极。OCEQ提供了关于学生对脸书群组作为学习平台满意度的更多证据。作业提交率为90%。小组作业成功率(得分≥60%)为100%。对开放式在线讨论的回复率为63%。通过同伴评价以及对在线讨论的直接观察,有证据表明与护理专业学生相比,女生和医学专业学生有明显贡献。
从学生的看法和表现可以看出,我们的IPE远程学习经历很有价值。医学专业学生和女生的积极性很明显。IPE是一个具有挑战性的过程。选修方式和使用远程学习可以提供解决方案。开展相关实践课程以及这种IPE电子学习经历的可持续性仍然是关键挑战。