Ludwig Boltzmann Institute of Osteology at Hanusch Hospital of OEGK and AUVA Trauma Centre Meidling, 1st Medical Department Hanusch Hospital, Heinrich Collin Strasse 30, 1140, Vienna, Austria.
Unit of Forensic Gerontology, Center of Forensic Science, Medical University of Vienna, Sensengasse 2, 1090, Vienna, Austria.
Calcif Tissue Int. 2021 Aug;109(2):190-202. doi: 10.1007/s00223-021-00832-5. Epub 2021 Apr 10.
Quantitative backscattered electron imaging is an established method to map mineral content distributions in bone and to determine the bone mineralization density distribution (BMDD). The method we applied was initially validated for a scanning electron microscope (SEM) equipped with a tungsten hairpin cathode (thermionic electron emission) under strongly defined settings of SEM parameters. For several reasons, it would be interesting to migrate the technique to a SEM with a field emission electron source (FE-SEM), which, however, would require to work with different SEM parameter settings as have been validated for DSM 962. The FE-SEM has a much better spatial resolution based on an electron source size in the order of several 100 nanometers, corresponding to an about [Formula: see text] to [Formula: see text] times smaller source area compared to thermionic sources. In the present work, we compare BMDD between these two types of instruments in order to further validate the methodology. We show that a transition to higher pixel resolution (1.76, 0.88, and 0.57 μm) results in shifts of the BMDD peak and BMDD width to higher values. Further the inter-device reproducibility of the mean calcium content shows a difference of up to 1 wt% Ca, while the technical variance of each device can be reduced to [Formula: see text] wt% Ca. Bearing in mind that shifts in calcium levels due to diseases, e.g., high turnover osteoporosis, are often in the range of 1 wt% Ca, both the bone samples of the patients as well as the control samples have to be measured on the same SEM device. Therefore, we also constructed new reference BMDD curves for adults to be used for FE-SEM data comparison.
定量背散射电子成像是一种成熟的方法,用于绘制骨矿物质含量分布并确定骨矿物质化密度分布(BMDD)。我们应用的方法最初是在配备钨发夹阴极(热电子发射)的扫描电子显微镜(SEM)中进行验证的,该方法在 SEM 参数的强定义设置下进行。出于多种原因,将该技术迁移到配备场发射电子源(FE-SEM)的 SEM 会很有趣,但是,这需要使用已经针对 DSM 962 进行验证的不同 SEM 参数设置。FE-SEM 的空间分辨率要好得多,这是基于电子源尺寸在几十纳米的范围内,与热电子源相比,源面积要小[Formula: see text]到[Formula: see text]倍。在本工作中,我们比较了这两种仪器之间的 BMDD,以进一步验证该方法。我们表明,向更高的像素分辨率(1.76、0.88 和 0.57 μm)的转变导致 BMDD 峰和 BMDD 宽度向更高的值移动。此外,设备间的平均钙含量的重现性差异高达 1wt% Ca,而每个设备的技术差异可降低至[Formula: see text]wt% Ca。考虑到由于疾病(例如高转换骨质疏松症)引起的钙水平变化通常在 1wt% Ca 的范围内,患者的骨样本和对照样本都必须在相同的 SEM 设备上进行测量。因此,我们还为成年人构建了新的参考 BMDD 曲线,用于 FE-SEM 数据比较。