Peng Ng Lai, Ling Eileen Koh Yi
SingHealth-Duke NUS Family Medicine Academic Clinical Programme, Singapore | Singhealth Polyclinics, Singapore.
Singhealth Polyclinics - Research, Singapore.
PRiMER. 2021 Jan 28;5:5. doi: 10.22454/PRiMER.2021.298435. eCollection 2021.
Intrauterine contraceptive device (IUCD) insertion is an important procedural skill for primary care physicians. Procedural skill training can be challenging. E-learning has been rapidly employed in medical education. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the role of a video-assisted e-learning module in knowledge and skill transfer for IUCD insertion training.
We used a quasi-experimental, one-group, pre/posttest study design. Thirty-one primary care doctors (family medicine residents and new medial officers) at a primary care training center participated in the study. All participants assessed the e-learning module at the training center. We performed on-site pre/posttests of knowledge and procedural steps (posttest only). We obtained satisfaction with e-learning and perceived confidence level with an anonymous questionnaire survey.
There was a significant increase in the knowledge test scores from a median interquartile range score of 12 (10-15) to 18 (17-19) post-e-learning (<.01). All participants attained the minimum passing score of 15 of 20 (75%) post-e-learning. However, only 20 of 31 (64.5%) participants met the minimum passing standard for procedural step test post-e-learning. Ninety-three percent of the participants reported satisfaction with the e-learning course. The median score for confidence level in performing the procedure increased significantly after e-learning.
The e-learning module may be an effective way of delivering instructional content in procedural training. It provides time and location flexibility and is useful for pretraining. Psychomotor skills for clinical procedures, however, may be difficult to acquire by e-learning alone. It must be supplemented with deliberate practice and hands-on learning in simulation workshops.
宫内节育器(IUCD)放置术是基层医疗医生一项重要的操作技能。操作技能培训颇具挑战性。电子学习已迅速应用于医学教育领域。本研究旨在评估视频辅助电子学习模块在IUCD放置术培训的知识与技能传授方面所起的作用。
我们采用了准实验性、单组、前后测研究设计。一家基层医疗培训中心的31名基层医疗医生(家庭医学住院医师和新入职的医务人员)参与了该研究。所有参与者在培训中心对电子学习模块进行了评估。我们对知识和操作步骤进行了现场前后测(仅后测)。通过匿名问卷调查获得对电子学习的满意度以及自我感知的信心水平。
电子学习后,知识测试分数显著提高,四分位间距中位数分数从12(10 - 15)提高到18(17 - 19)(<.01)。所有参与者在电子学习后均达到了20分中15分(75%)的最低及格分数。然而,在电子学习后,31名参与者中只有20名(64.5%)达到了操作步骤测试的最低及格标准。93%的参与者报告对电子学习课程满意。电子学习后,进行该操作的信心水平中位数分数显著提高。
电子学习模块可能是在操作培训中传授教学内容的一种有效方式。它提供了时间和地点的灵活性,对预培训很有用。然而,临床操作的心理运动技能可能难以仅通过电子学习获得。必须辅以在模拟工作坊中的刻意练习和实践操作学习。