Curtis Sarah, Martin Heather, DiNella Michelle, Lavallee Barry, Chartrand Caroline, McLeod Lorraine, Woods Cathy, Dart Allison, Tangri Navdeep, Rigatto Claudio, Komenda Paul
Chronic Disease Innovation Center, Seven Oaks General Hospital, Winnipeg, MB, Canada.
Diabetes Integration Project, Winnipeg, MB, Canada.
Can J Kidney Health Dis. 2021 Mar 31;8:20543581211003744. doi: 10.1177/20543581211003744. eCollection 2021.
Access to health care services remains a significant barrier for many Indigenous people's living in rural and remote regions of Canada. Driven by geographical isolation and compounded by socioeconomic and environmental disparities, individuals living under these circumstances face disproportionately poor health outcomes. Kidney Check is a comprehensive screening, triage, and treatment initiative working to bring culturally safe preventive care to rural and remote Indigenous communities across Manitoba, Ontario, BC, Alberta, and Saskatchewan. The project's patient-oriented approach addresses concerns raised by kidney patients and their caregivers using culturally safe practices. Using the various expertise of their multidisciplinary team, Kidney Check seeks to further collaborative efforts to improve access to preventive health care for these groups. Meaningful engagement with patients, communities, and local health care stakeholders ensures Indigenous voices are heard and incorporated into the project in a way that promotes shared decision-making and sustainability.
As an affiliate program of the Can-SOLVE CKD Network, Kidney Check's guiding priorities were developed over 3 years of patient consultation and finalized during 2 workshops held with more than 30 patients, caregivers, Indigenous peoples, researchers, and policy makers using a modified Delphi process. Today, patients continue to participate in project development via 2 governing bodies: The Patient Governance Circle and the Indigenous Peoples Engagement and Research Council (IPERC).
Modeled after the Indigenous-led 2015 FINISHED project in Manitoba, Kidney Check employs point-of-care testing to identify diabetes, hypertension, and chronic kidney disease (CKD) in individuals, ages 10 and above, regardless of pre-existing risk factors. The Kidney Check team consists of 4 working groups: project leadership, provincial management, local community partners, and patient partners. By using and building on existing relationships between local and provincial health care stakeholders and various Indigenous communities, the program furthers collaborative efforts to bridge gaps in health equity.
The Kidney Check program has established an infrastructure that integrates patient engagement at all stages of the program from priority setting to deployment and dissemination strategies.
While we encourage and offer screening services to all, many still choose not to attend for a variety of reasons which may introduce selection bias. Kidney Check uses patient engagement as a foundational component of the program; however, there is currently a limited amount of research documenting the benefits of patient engagement in health care settings. More formal qualitative evaluations of these activities are needed. In addition, as the COVID-19 pandemic has halted screening procedures in most communities, we currently do not have quantitative data to support the efficacy of the Kidney Check program.
For many Indigenous people, lack of accessibility to health care services is compounded by sociopolitical barriers that disrupt relationships between patients and providers. Meaningful engagement presents one opportunity to ensure the voices and perspectives of Indigenous patients and communities are incorporated into health services. In addition, this screening paradigm has shown to be cost effective as shown by analyses done on the FINISHED screening program.
对于许多生活在加拿大农村和偏远地区的原住民而言,获得医疗保健服务仍然是一个重大障碍。受地理隔离的影响,再加上社会经济和环境方面的差异,生活在这种环境下的个人面临着极其糟糕的健康状况。肾脏检查是一项全面的筛查、分诊和治疗计划,致力于为曼尼托巴省、安大略省、不列颠哥伦比亚省、艾伯塔省和萨斯喀彻温省农村和偏远的原住民社区提供具有文化安全性的预防性护理。该项目以患者为导向的方法,运用具有文化安全性的做法,解决了肾病患者及其护理人员提出的问题。肾脏检查利用其多学科团队的各种专业知识,寻求进一步的合作努力,以改善这些群体获得预防性医疗保健的机会。与患者、社区和当地医疗保健利益相关者进行有意义的互动,确保原住民的声音能够被倾听,并以促进共同决策和可持续性的方式纳入该项目。
作为加拿大慢性肾脏病解决方案网络(Can-SOLVE CKD Network)的附属项目,肾脏检查的指导重点是在3年的患者咨询过程中制定的,并在与30多名患者、护理人员、原住民、研究人员和政策制定者举行的2次研讨会上,通过改进的德尔菲法最终确定。如今,患者继续通过两个管理机构参与项目开发:患者治理圈和原住民参与及研究委员会(IPERC)。
肾脏检查仿照2015年在曼尼托巴省由原住民主导的“完成”(FINISHED)项目,采用即时检测来识别10岁及以上个体中的糖尿病、高血压和慢性肾脏病(CKD),无论其是否存在既往风险因素。肾脏检查团队由4个工作组组成:项目领导层、省级管理层、当地社区合作伙伴和患者合作伙伴。通过利用并加强当地和省级医疗保健利益相关者与各个原住民社区之间的现有关系,该项目进一步推动合作努力,以弥合健康公平方面的差距。
肾脏检查项目建立了一个基础设施,将患者参与融入到项目从确定优先事项到部署和传播策略的各个阶段。
虽然我们鼓励并为所有人提供筛查服务,但许多人仍因各种原因选择不参加,这可能会引入选择偏倚。肾脏检查将患者参与作为项目的一个基本组成部分;然而,目前记录患者参与医疗保健环境益处的研究数量有限。需要对这些活动进行更正式的定性评估。此外,由于新冠疫情已在大多数社区停止了筛查程序,我们目前没有定量数据来支持肾脏检查项目的有效性。
对许多原住民来说,获得医疗保健服务的困难因社会政治障碍而加剧,这些障碍破坏了患者与提供者之间的关系。有意义的参与提供了一个机会,以确保原住民患者和社区的声音和观点能够纳入医疗服务。此外,正如对“完成”筛查项目所做的分析表明,这种筛查模式已被证明具有成本效益。