Departament of Oral Diagnosis, Piracicaba Dental School, University of Campinas, Piracicaba, São Paulo, Brasil.
Department of Dentistry, Undergraduate student of Dentistry, Federal University of Sergipe, Sergipe, Brazil.
Dentomaxillofac Radiol. 2022 Sep 1;51(6):20200548. doi: 10.1259/dmfr.20200548. Epub 2022 Aug 5.
To assess the reliability of CEFBOT, an artificial intelligence (AI)-based cephalometry software, for cephalometric landmark annotation and linear and angular measurements according to Arnett's analysis.
Thirty lateral cephalometric radiographs acquired with a Carestream CS 9000 3D unit (Carestream Health Inc., Rochester/NY) were used in this study. The 66 landmarks and the 10 selected linear and angular measurements of Arnett's analysis were identified on each radiograph by a trained human examiner (control) and by CEFBOT (RadioMemory Ltd., Belo Horizonte, Brazil). For both methods, landmark annotations and measurements were duplicated with an interval of 15 days between measurements and the intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) was calculated to determine reliability. The numerical values obtained with the two methods were compared by a -test for independent variables.
CEFBOT was able to perform all but one of the 10 measurements. ICC values > 0.94 were found for the remaining eight measurements, while the Frankfurt horizontal plane - true horizontal line (THL) angular measurement showed the lowest reproducibility (human, ICC = 0.876; CEFBOT, ICC = 0.768). Measurements performed by the human examiner and by CEFBOT were not statistically different.
Within the limitations of our methodology, we concluded that the AI contained in the CEFBOT software can be considered a promising tool for enhancing the capacities of human radiologists.
评估 CEFBOT,一种基于人工智能(AI)的头影测量软件,在根据 Arnett 分析进行头影测量标志点标注和线性及角度测量方面的可靠性。
本研究使用了 30 张由 Carestream CS 9000 3D 设备(Carestream Health Inc.,罗彻斯特/纽约)获取的侧位头颅 X 光片。每张 X 光片均由经过培训的人类检查者(对照组)和 CEFBOT(巴西贝洛哈里桑塔的 RadioMemory Ltd.)识别 66 个标志点和 Arnett 分析的 10 个选定的线性和角度测量值。对于这两种方法,标志点标注和测量值在测量之间间隔 15 天进行重复,并计算组内相关系数(ICC)以确定可靠性。通过独立变量的 t 检验比较两种方法获得的数值。
CEFBOT 能够进行除一项测量外的所有 10 项测量。其余 8 项测量的 ICC 值>0.94,而法兰克福水平面-真水平线(THL)角度测量的可重复性最低(人类,ICC=0.876;CEFBOT,ICC=0.768)。人类检查者和 CEFBOT 进行的测量在统计学上没有差异。
在我们的方法学限制内,我们得出结论,CEFBOT 软件中包含的人工智能可以被视为增强人类放射科医生能力的有前途的工具。