Wahi Gita, de Souza Russell J, Hartmann Katrina, Giglia Lucia, Jack Susan M, Anand Sonia S
Departments of Pediatrics, Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University, Canada.
Department of Health Research Methods, Evidence and Impact, Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University, Canada.
Prev Med Rep. 2021 Mar 9;22:101347. doi: 10.1016/j.pmedr.2021.101347. eCollection 2021 Jun.
Given the significant health burden of childhood obesity, it is imperative that effective programs be better understood. When evaluating obesity prevention efforts, one must recognize the contextual factors which drive the disproportionate risk of obesity between populations. This systematic review sought to understand if programs aimed at obesity prevention and/or the promotion of healthy lifestyle behaviours for Indigenous children are effective. We conducted a search using Medline, EMBASE, PsychINFO, ERIC, CINAHL and iPORTAL databases from inception to August 13, 2019. We included experimental and quasi-experimental studies. The main outcomes of interest were change in anthropometrics, nutrition or physical activity. Our narrative synthesis included an assessment of study quality using the Effective Public Health Practice Project Quality assessment tool. A total of 34 studies met selection criteria. Most studies used a quasi-experimental design (n = 25) and were assessed as low to moderate quality (n = 32). Three studies showed a significant change in anthropometric measures, 14 studies demonstrated at least one significant nutrition-related behaviour or dietary-pattern change, and six studies demonstrated a significant impact on physical activity. This systematic review of programs to prevent obesity among Indigenous children finds a limited impact on anthropometric measurements. Future studies must prioritize Indigenous knowledge and ways of knowing to lead all phases of development, implementation, and evaluation of programs.
鉴于儿童肥胖带来的巨大健康负担,必须更好地理解有效的项目。在评估肥胖预防工作时,必须认识到导致不同人群肥胖风险不成比例的背景因素。本系统综述旨在了解针对土著儿童的肥胖预防和/或促进健康生活方式行为的项目是否有效。我们使用Medline、EMBASE、PsychINFO、ERIC、CINAHL和iPORTAL数据库进行了检索,检索时间跨度从各数据库建库至2019年8月13日。我们纳入了实验性和准实验性研究。主要关注的结果是人体测量学、营养或身体活动方面的变化。我们的叙述性综合分析包括使用有效公共卫生实践项目质量评估工具对研究质量进行评估。共有34项研究符合入选标准。大多数研究采用准实验设计(n = 25),质量评估为低到中等(n = 32)。三项研究显示人体测量指标有显著变化,14项研究表明至少有一项与营养相关的行为或饮食模式有显著变化,六项研究表明对身体活动有显著影响。这项针对预防土著儿童肥胖项目的系统综述发现,这些项目对人体测量指标的影响有限。未来的研究必须优先考虑土著知识和认知方式,以指导项目开发、实施和评估的各个阶段。