Beresford Shirley Aa, Rillamas-Sun Eileen, Rudd Kassia, Bishop Sonia K, Deschenie Desiree, Ornelas India J, Bauer Mark C, Lombard Kevin A
Department of Epidemiology, School of Public Health, University of Washington, Seattle, WA, United States.
Division of Public Health Sciences, Fred Hutchinson Cancer Center, Seattle, WA, United States.
Curr Dev Nutr. 2023 Apr 1;7(5):100074. doi: 10.1016/j.cdnut.2023.100074. eCollection 2023 May.
To estimate the efficacy of interventions to improve healthy eating, valid measures are essential. Although simple dietary intake tools have been developed with other populations, few have been culturally tailored and assessed for validity and reliability among Navajo.
This study aimed to develop a simple dietary intake tool tailored to Navajo culture, derive healthy eating indices, and assess their validity and reliability in Navajo children and adults and to describe the process used to develop this tool.
A picture-sort tool using typically consumed foods was developed. Elementary school children and family members provided qualitative feedback in focus groups, used to refine the tool. Next, school-aged children and adults completed assessments at baseline and follow-up. Baseline behavior measures including child self-efficacy for fruits and vegetables (F&V) were examined for internal consistency. Healthy eating indices were derived from intake frequencies from picture sorting. The convergent validity of the indices and behavior measures for children and adults were examined. The reliability of the indices at the 2 time points was derived using Bland-Altman plots.
The picture-sort was refined from feedback provided by the focus groups. Baseline measures from 25 children and 18 adults were obtained. In children, a modified Alternative Healthy Eating Index (AHEI) and 2 other indices from the picture-sort were correlated with self-efficacy for eating F&V and had good reliability. In adults, the modified AHEI and 3 other indices from the picture-sort had significant correlations with adult abbreviated food frequency of F&V or obesogenic dietary index and had good reliability.
The Navajo foods picture-sort tool developed for Navajo children and adults is proven to be acceptable and feasible to implement. Indices derived from the tool has good convergent validity and repeatability, supporting use in evaluating dietary change interventions in Navajo, with the potential for broader use of the approach in other underserved populations.
为评估改善健康饮食干预措施的效果,有效的测量方法至关重要。尽管已针对其他人群开发了简单的饮食摄入工具,但很少有工具针对纳瓦霍族文化进行调整并评估其在纳瓦霍族中的有效性和可靠性。
本研究旨在开发一种针对纳瓦霍族文化的简单饮食摄入工具,得出健康饮食指数,并评估其在纳瓦霍族儿童和成人中的有效性和可靠性,同时描述开发该工具所采用的过程。
开发了一种使用常见食用食物的图片分类工具。小学生和家庭成员在焦点小组中提供定性反馈,用于完善该工具。接下来,学龄儿童和成人在基线和随访时完成评估。对包括儿童对水果和蔬菜的自我效能感在内的基线行为指标进行内部一致性检验。从图片分类的摄入频率中得出健康饮食指数。检验儿童和成人指数与行为指标的收敛效度。使用布兰德 - 奥特曼图得出两个时间点指数的可靠性。
根据焦点小组提供的反馈对图片分类进行了完善。获得了25名儿童和18名成人的基线测量数据。在儿童中,改良的替代健康饮食指数(AHEI)和图片分类中的其他两个指数与食用水果和蔬菜的自我效能感相关,且可靠性良好。在成人中,改良的AHEI和图片分类中的其他三个指数与成人水果和蔬菜的简略食物频率或致肥胖饮食指数显著相关,且可靠性良好。
为纳瓦霍族儿童和成人开发的纳瓦霍族食物图片分类工具经证实可接受且实施可行。从该工具得出的指数具有良好的收敛效度和可重复性,支持其用于评估纳瓦霍族的饮食变化干预措施,该方法有可能在其他服务不足的人群中更广泛地应用。