Department of Preventive Dental Sciences, Taibah University Dental College and Hospital, Al-Madinah Al-Munawwarah, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, Phone: +966 50 466 5331, e-mail:
Faculty of Dentistry, King Abdulaziz University, Jeddah, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia.
J Contemp Dent Pract. 2020 Dec 1;21(12):1331-1336.
This study sought to examine the effectiveness of hybrid learning utilizing WhatsApp as an adjunct to traditional learning in delivering knowledge to and supporting the learning of undergraduate dental students and investigate learner perceptions of WhatsApp use in educational contexts.
The 3-month prospective analytical interventional study sampled 85 undergraduate students from the Department of Preventive Dental Sciences. A WhatsApp group was created, information was sent to the male and female groups, and a written assignment was used as a performance benchmark of knowledge acquisition and application. Perceptions of e-learning through WhatsApp were assessed using a previously validated and published questionnaire. Collected data underwent descriptive and bivariate analyses (unpaired -test).
The average assignment scores of the 85 hybrid learners were statistically significantly higher than those of traditional learners from the previous academic year (34 ± 1 vs 26 ± 3; < 0.05, respectively). Meanwhile, 57 hybrid learners completed the survey, and 73% agreed/strongly agreed that introducing a new method of teaching via WhatsApp was useful, 70% reported that a professional and comfortable learning environment was created, and 70% felt that group distractions were handled appropriately. The top advantages of learning through WhatsApp were availability/immediacy (94.7%) and being simple to operate (91.2%). Males (40.4%) were significantly more likely to report a sense of belonging to the group than females (33.3%, = 0.01). Respondents agreed that high expectations of teacher availability (71.9%) and some students making no effort (52.6%) were challenges. Message flooding (45.6%) and time-consuming nature of WhatsApp (36.8%) were identified as technical challenges.
The findings showed significant improvements in student performance using the hybrid learning tool, as reflected in assignment scores. Positive perceptions of hybrid learning and improved academic performance indicate that WhatsApp is a convenient new teaching tool.
The results of this study may be applicable to other clinical dental disciplines.
本研究旨在考察利用 WhatsApp 进行混合学习的效果,将其作为传统学习的辅助手段,向本科牙科学生传授知识并支持他们的学习,并调查学习者对 WhatsApp 在教育环境中使用的看法。
这项为期 3 个月的前瞻性分析性干预研究从预防牙科科学系抽取了 85 名本科学生。创建了一个 WhatsApp 群组,向男女群组发送信息,并使用书面作业作为知识获取和应用的绩效基准。使用之前经过验证和发表的问卷评估通过 WhatsApp 进行电子学习的看法。收集的数据进行了描述性和双变量分析(非配对检验)。
85 名混合学习者的平均作业成绩明显高于上一学年的传统学习者(34 ± 1 对 26 ± 3;分别为 < 0.05)。同时,57 名混合学习者完成了调查,73%的人同意/强烈同意通过 WhatsApp 引入新的教学方法很有用,70%的人报告说创造了一个专业和舒适的学习环境,70%的人认为小组干扰得到了妥善处理。通过 WhatsApp 学习的最大优势是可用性/即时性(94.7%)和操作简单(91.2%)。男性(40.4%)比女性(33.3%, = 0.01)更有可能报告对小组的归属感。受访者同意,教师可用性的高期望(71.9%)和一些学生不努力(52.6%)是挑战。消息泛滥(45.6%)和 WhatsApp 的耗时性质(36.8%)被认为是技术挑战。
研究结果表明,学生使用混合学习工具的表现有了显著提高,反映在作业成绩上。混合学习的积极看法和学术成绩的提高表明,WhatsApp 是一种方便的新教学工具。
本研究的结果可能适用于其他临床牙科学科。