Bernard-Espina Jules, Beraneck Mathieu, Maier Marc A, Tagliabue Michele
Université de Paris, INCC UMR 8002, CNRS, Paris, France.
Front Neurosci. 2021 Apr 7;15:646698. doi: 10.3389/fnins.2021.646698. eCollection 2021.
For reaching and grasping, as well as for manipulating objects, optimal hand motor control arises from the integration of multiple sources of sensory information, such as proprioception and vision. For this reason, proprioceptive deficits often observed in stroke patients have a significant impact on the integrity of motor functions. The present targeted review attempts to reanalyze previous findings about proprioceptive upper-limb deficits in stroke patients, as well as their ability to compensate for these deficits using vision. Our theoretical approach is based on two concepts: first, the description of multi-sensory integration using statistical optimization models; second, on the insight that sensory information is not only encoded in the reference frame of origin (e.g., retinal and joint space for vision and proprioception, respectively), but also in higher-order sensory spaces. Combining these two concepts within a single framework appears to account for the heterogeneity of experimental findings reported in the literature. The present analysis suggests that functional upper limb post-stroke deficits could not only be due to an impairment of the proprioceptive system per se, but also due to deficiencies of cross-references processing; that is of the ability to encode proprioceptive information in a non-joint space. The distinction between purely proprioceptive or cross-reference-related deficits can account for two experimental observations: first, one and the same patient can perform differently depending on specific proprioceptive assessments; and a given behavioral assessment results in large variability across patients. The distinction between sensory and cross-reference deficits is also supported by a targeted literature review on the relation between cerebral structure and proprioceptive function. This theoretical framework has the potential to lead to a new stratification of patients with proprioceptive deficits, and may offer a novel approach to post-stroke rehabilitation.
对于伸手抓握以及操作物体而言,最佳的手部运动控制源于多种感觉信息源的整合,比如本体感觉和视觉。因此,中风患者中经常观察到的本体感觉缺陷会对运动功能的完整性产生重大影响。本项针对性综述试图重新分析先前关于中风患者上肢本体感觉缺陷的研究结果,以及他们利用视觉补偿这些缺陷的能力。我们的理论方法基于两个概念:第一,使用统计优化模型描述多感觉整合;第二,基于这样一种见解,即感觉信息不仅在其原始参照系中编码(例如,视觉和本体感觉分别在视网膜和关节空间中编码),而且也在高阶感觉空间中编码。在单一框架内结合这两个概念似乎可以解释文献中报道的实验结果的异质性。目前的分析表明,中风后上肢功能缺陷不仅可能归因于本体感觉系统本身的损伤,还可能归因于交叉参照处理的缺陷;也就是说,在非关节空间中编码本体感觉信息的能力存在缺陷。纯粹本体感觉缺陷或与交叉参照相关的缺陷之间的区别可以解释两个实验观察结果:第一,同一个患者根据特定的本体感觉评估可能表现不同;第二,给定的行为评估在不同患者之间会产生很大差异。关于大脑结构与本体感觉功能之间关系的针对性文献综述也支持了感觉缺陷和交叉参照缺陷之间的区别。这一理论框架有可能导致对本体感觉缺陷患者进行新的分层,并可能为中风后康复提供一种新方法。