Division of Cardiology University of California San Francisco San Francisco CA.
Division of Cardiology Zuckerberg San Francisco General Hospital San Francisco CA.
J Am Heart Assoc. 2021 May 4;10(9):e019905. doi: 10.1161/JAHA.120.019905. Epub 2021 Apr 26.
Background Clinicians vary markedly in their ability to detect murmurs during cardiac auscultation and identify the underlying pathological features. Deep learning approaches have shown promise in medicine by transforming collected data into clinically significant information. The objective of this research is to assess the performance of a deep learning algorithm to detect murmurs and clinically significant valvular heart disease using recordings from a commercial digital stethoscope platform. Methods and Results Using >34 hours of previously acquired and annotated heart sound recordings, we trained a deep neural network to detect murmurs. To test the algorithm, we enrolled 962 patients in a clinical study and collected recordings at the 4 primary auscultation locations. Ground truth was established using patient echocardiograms and annotations by 3 expert cardiologists. Algorithm performance for detecting murmurs has sensitivity and specificity of 76.3% and 91.4%, respectively. By omitting softer murmurs, those with grade 1 intensity, sensitivity increased to 90.0%. Application of the algorithm at the appropriate anatomic auscultation location detected moderate-to-severe or greater aortic stenosis, with sensitivity of 93.2% and specificity of 86.0%, and moderate-to-severe or greater mitral regurgitation, with sensitivity of 66.2% and specificity of 94.6%. Conclusions The deep learning algorithm's ability to detect murmurs and clinically significant aortic stenosis and mitral regurgitation is comparable to expert cardiologists based on the annotated subset of our database. The findings suggest that such algorithms would have utility as front-line clinical support tools to aid clinicians in screening for cardiac murmurs caused by valvular heart disease. Registration URL: https://clinicaltrials.gov; Unique Identifier: NCT03458806.
临床医生在听诊心脏杂音和识别潜在病理特征方面的能力差异很大。深度学习方法通过将收集到的数据转化为具有临床意义的信息,在医学领域显示出了巨大的潜力。本研究旨在评估一种深度学习算法在使用商业数字听诊器平台记录的音频数据检测杂音和有临床意义的瓣膜性心脏病方面的性能。
我们使用超过 34 小时的先前采集并已注释的心音记录来训练深度神经网络以检测杂音。为了测试算法,我们在一项临床研究中招募了 962 名患者,并在 4 个主要听诊部位采集了记录。使用患者的超声心动图和 3 位专家心脏病学家的注释来确定算法的性能。该算法检测杂音的敏感性和特异性分别为 76.3%和 91.4%。通过忽略强度为 1 级的较柔和的杂音,敏感性提高到 90.0%。在适当的解剖听诊位置应用该算法可以检测出中重度或更严重的主动脉瓣狭窄,敏感性为 93.2%,特异性为 86.0%,以及中重度或更严重的二尖瓣反流,敏感性为 66.2%,特异性为 94.6%。
基于我们数据库的注释子集,深度学习算法检测杂音和有临床意义的主动脉瓣狭窄和二尖瓣反流的能力与专家心脏病学家相当。这些发现表明,此类算法将作为一线临床支持工具具有实用价值,有助于临床医生筛查由瓣膜性心脏病引起的心脏杂音。