Division of Health Policy and Management, College of Health Science, Korea University, 02841 Seoul, South Korea.
Interdisciplinary Program in Precision Public Health, Department of Public Health Sciences, Graduate School of Korea University, 02841 Seoul, South Korea.
Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2021 May 4;118(18). doi: 10.1073/pnas.2025865118.
There are emerging opportunities to assess health indicators at truly small areas with increasing availability of data geocoded to micro geographic units and advanced modeling techniques. The utility of such fine-grained data can be fully leveraged if linked to local governance units that are accountable for implementation of programs and interventions. We used data from the 2011 Indian Census for village-level demographic and amenities features and the 2016 Indian Demographic and Health Survey in a bias-corrected semisupervised regression framework to predict child anthropometric failures for all villages in India. Of the total geographic variation in predicted child anthropometric failure estimates, 54.2 to 72.3% were attributed to the village level followed by 20.6 to 39.5% to the state level. The mean predicted stunting was 37.9% (SD: 10.1%; IQR: 31.2 to 44.7%), and substantial variation was found across villages ranging from less than 5% for 691 villages to over 70% in 453 villages. Estimates at the village level can potentially shift the paradigm of policy discussion in India by enabling more informed prioritization and precise targeting. The proposed methodology can be adapted and applied to diverse population health indicators, and in other contexts, to reveal spatial heterogeneity at a finer geographic scale and identify local areas with the greatest needs and with direct implications for actions to take place.
随着越来越多的数据被地理编码到微观地理单元和先进的建模技术,评估真正小区域的健康指标的机会正在出现。如果将这些精细粒度的数据链接到负责实施计划和干预的地方治理单位,那么这些数据的实用性可以得到充分利用。我们使用了 2011 年印度人口普查的村庄级人口和便利设施特征数据以及 2016 年印度人口与健康调查的数据,在带有偏差校正的半监督回归框架中预测了印度所有村庄的儿童体格发育失败情况。在预测儿童体格发育失败估计值的总地理变化中,54.2%至 72.3%归因于村庄层面,其次是 20.6%至 39.5%归因于邦层面。平均预测发育迟缓率为 37.9%(标准差:10.1%;IQR:31.2 至 44.7%),在不同村庄之间存在很大差异,691 个村庄的发育迟缓率不到 5%,而 453 个村庄的发育迟缓率超过 70%。村庄层面的估计值可能会通过更明智的优先级排序和更精确的目标定位,改变印度政策讨论的模式。所提出的方法可以适应和应用于不同的人口健康指标,以及在其他情况下,以更精细的地理尺度揭示空间异质性,并确定最需要的当地地区,这对采取行动具有直接影响。