Gerhalter Teresa, Chen Anna M, Dehkharghani Seena, Peralta Rosemary, Adlparvar Fatemeh, Babb James S, Bushnik Tamara, Silver Jonathan M, Im Brian S, Wall Stephen P, Brown Ryan, Baete Steven H, Kirov Ivan I, Madelin Guillaume
Department of Radiology, Center for Biomedical Imaging, New York University Grossman School of Medicine, New York, NY 10016, USA.
Department of Neurology, New York University Grossman School of Medicine, New York, NY 10016, USA.
Brain Commun. 2021 Mar 23;3(2):fcab051. doi: 10.1093/braincomms/fcab051. eCollection 2021.
The pathological cascade of tissue damage in mild traumatic brain injury is set forth by a perturbation in ionic homeostasis. However, whether this class of injury can be detected and serve as a surrogate marker of clinical outcome is unknown. We employ sodium MRI to test the hypotheses that regional and global total sodium concentrations: (i) are higher in patients than in controls and (ii) correlate with clinical presentation and neuropsychological function. Given the novelty of sodium imaging in traumatic brain injury, effect sizes from (i), and correlation types and strength from (ii), were compared to those obtained using standard diffusion imaging metrics. Twenty-seven patients (20 female, age 35.9 ± 12.2 years) within 2 months after injury and 19 controls were scanned with proton and sodium MRI at 3 Tesla. Total sodium concentration, fractional anisotropy and apparent diffusion coefficient were obtained with voxel averaging across 12 grey and white matter regions. Linear regression was used to obtain global grey and white matter total sodium concentrations. Patient outcome was assessed with global functioning, symptom profiles and neuropsychological function assessments. In the regional analysis, there were no statistically significant differences between patients and controls in apparent diffusion coefficient, while differences in sodium concentration and fractional anisotropy were found only in single regions. However, for each of the 12 regions, sodium concentration effect sizes were uni-directional, due to lower mean sodium concentration in patients compared to controls. Consequently, linear regression analysis found statistically significant lower global grey and white matter sodium concentrations in patients compared to controls. The strongest correlation with outcome was between global grey matter sodium concentration and the composite -score from the neuropsychological testing. In conclusion, both sodium concentration and diffusion showed poor utility in differentiating patients from controls, and weak correlations with clinical presentation, when using a region-based approach. In contrast, sodium linear regression, capitalizing on partial volume correction and high sensitivity to global changes, revealed high effect sizes and associations with patient outcome. This suggests that well-recognized sodium imbalances in traumatic brain injury are (i) detectable non-invasively; (ii) non-focal; (iii) occur even when the antecedent injury is clinically mild. Finally, in contrast to our principle hypothesis, patients' sodium concentrations were than controls, indicating that the biological effect of traumatic brain injury on the sodium homeostasis may differ from that in other neurological disorders. Note: This figure has been annotated.
轻度创伤性脑损伤中组织损伤的病理级联反应是由离子稳态的扰动引发的。然而,这类损伤能否被检测到并作为临床结果的替代标志物尚不清楚。我们采用钠磁共振成像来检验以下假设:区域和整体总钠浓度:(i)患者高于对照组;(ii)与临床表现和神经心理功能相关。鉴于钠成像在创伤性脑损伤中的新颖性,将(i)中的效应大小以及(ii)中的相关类型和强度与使用标准扩散成像指标获得的结果进行了比较。对27名受伤后2个月内的患者(20名女性,年龄35.9±12.2岁)和19名对照组进行了3特斯拉的质子和钠磁共振成像扫描。通过对12个灰质和白质区域进行体素平均获得总钠浓度、分数各向异性和表观扩散系数。使用线性回归获得整体灰质和白质总钠浓度。通过整体功能、症状概况和神经心理功能评估来评估患者的预后。在区域分析中,患者和对照组在表观扩散系数方面没有统计学上的显著差异,而仅在单个区域发现了钠浓度和分数各向异性的差异。然而,对于12个区域中的每一个,由于患者的平均钠浓度低于对照组,钠浓度效应大小是单向的。因此,线性回归分析发现,与对照组相比,患者的整体灰质和白质钠浓度在统计学上显著较低。与预后最强的相关性存在于整体灰质钠浓度与神经心理测试的综合评分之间。总之,当采用基于区域的方法时,钠浓度和扩散在区分患者与对照组方面效用不佳,且与临床表现的相关性较弱。相比之下,利用部分容积校正和对整体变化的高敏感性的钠线性回归显示出高效应大小以及与患者预后的关联。这表明创伤性脑损伤中公认的钠失衡是(i)可通过非侵入性检测到的;(ii)非局灶性的;(iii)即使先前的损伤在临床上很轻微也会发生。最后,与我们的主要假设相反,患者的钠浓度低于对照组,这表明创伤性脑损伤对钠稳态的生物学影响可能与其他神经系统疾病不同。注意:此图已标注。