D'Orta Isabella, Herrmann François R, Giannakopoulos Panteleimon
Division of Institutional Measures, Medical Direction, Geneva University Hospitals, Geneva, Switzerland.
Department of Rehabilitation and Geriatrics, Geneva University Hospitals and University of Geneva, Geneva, Switzerland.
Front Psychiatry. 2021 Apr 15;12:626773. doi: 10.3389/fpsyt.2021.626773. eCollection 2021.
Among the different types of heavy use of mental health services, frequent inpatient admission in acute care units of individuals unable to return to their usual environment refers to as revolving-door (RD). RD in prisoners is related to increased violence (acted and supported) and suicidal recidivism. We explored the determinants of RD in 200 inmates from the Swiss-French speaking areas who were admitted to the sole acute psychiatric care unit for all of the Swiss-French counties, located in Geneva. The Cuzick's test for trend across ordered groups, Kruskal-Wallis test and oneway ANOVA were used to compare demographic and clinical variables between single (one admission, = 100), frequent (3-7, = 69) and RD (more than 8, = 31) during a 12 months period. In addition, univariate and multivariable ordered logistic regression modes were built to examine the determinants of RD. The sample included 27 women (mean age: 31.2 years) and 173 men (34.5 years) who were admitted during the period 2014-2019. The vast majority were single (65%) with low level of education (<6 years, 78%). Suicidal behavior was the more frequent reason for admission (57%). Psychiatric history was positive in 77.5% of cases and in 54.5% of cases there was at least one episode of inpatient psychiatric care. The more frequent ICD-10 psychiatric diagnosis in the last admission were psychotic disorder (38%), personality disorder (29.5%) and adjustment disorder (19.5%). In contrast, depressive episodes (7%) and bipolar disorder (4.5%) were rare. Group comparison showed that the presence of court-ordered treatments, suicidal behavior, personality and psychotic disorders was associated with significantly increased frequency of RD use. In univariate models, the same factors were positively associated with RD, the highest odds ratio being found for court-ordered treatments (5.77) and personality disorders (2.14). In contrast, the diagnosis of adjustment disorders was related to decreased RD use (OR 0.25). Court-ordered treatments and personality disorders were the only factors to predict RD in multivariable regression models. These findings suggest that acute psychiatric care in these patients did not depend of environmental stressors but rather represents the expression of a long-lasting vulnerability related to their psychological profile and criminal status.
在不同类型的频繁使用心理健康服务中,无法回到其正常环境的个体在急性护理单元频繁住院被称为“旋转门”(RD)。囚犯中的RD与暴力行为增加(实际发生和受支持的)以及自杀复发有关。我们对来自瑞士法语区的200名囚犯进行了研究,这些囚犯被收治到位于日内瓦的、服务于瑞士所有法语县的唯一急性精神病护理单元。采用Cuzick趋势检验(用于有序组间)、Kruskal-Wallis检验和单因素方差分析来比较12个月期间单次住院(一次入院,n = 100)、频繁住院(3 - 7次,n = 69)和“旋转门”住院(超过8次,n = 31)之间的人口统计学和临床变量。此外,构建了单变量和多变量有序逻辑回归模型来研究“旋转门”住院的决定因素。样本包括2014 - 2019年期间收治的27名女性(平均年龄:31.2岁)和173名男性(34.5岁)。绝大多数为单身(65%)且教育程度低(<6年,78%)。自杀行为是最常见的入院原因(57%)。77.5%的病例有精神病史,54.5%的病例至少有一次住院精神科护理经历。上次入院时最常见的ICD - 10精神科诊断为精神障碍(38%)、人格障碍(29.5%)和适应障碍(19.5%)。相比之下,抑郁发作(7%)和双相情感障碍(4.5%)很少见。组间比较显示,存在法院强制治疗、自杀行为、人格和精神障碍与“旋转门”住院使用频率显著增加有关。在单变量模型中,相同因素与“旋转门”住院呈正相关,法院强制治疗(5.77)和人格障碍(2.14)的优势比最高。相比之下,适应障碍的诊断与“旋转门”住院使用减少有关(OR = 0.25)。在多变量回归模型中,法院强制治疗和人格障碍是预测“旋转门”住院的唯一因素。这些发现表明,这些患者的急性精神病护理并非取决于环境应激源,而是代表了与其心理特征和犯罪状况相关的长期易损性的一种表现。